Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ])

Transcription

1 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Tue, 27 Nov :08: Received: from p01c11m016.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id 61CAB19E8190 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Tue, 27 Nov :34: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO smtp.cybermesa.com) by p01c11m016.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id b2f4c p01c11m016.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <fairdinkm@cybermesa.com>); Tue, 27 Nov :08: (MST) Received: from workhorse (albcmcs1-du125.cybermesa.com [ ]) by smtp.cybermesa.com (8.13.1/8.13.1) with SMTP id larh8lsl for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Tue, 27 Nov :08: $MessageID: <000a01c83118$2c2ef470$7d2b1341@workhorse> From: "judy fair" <fairdinkm@cybermesa.com> SendTo: <r2fwe_al@fws.gov> Subject: written comments submission PostedDate: 11/27/ :08:40 AM MIME_Version: 1.0 DeliveryPriority: N X_MSMail_Priority: Normal $Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express X_MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V X_Spam_Score: () AWL,HTML_MESSAGE 100 X_Scanned_By: MIMEDefang 2.54 on X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.012( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.009( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <fairdinkm@cybermesa.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/27/ :08:59 AM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:36 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:36 AM SMTPOriginator: fairdinkm@cybermesa.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/27/ :08:59 AM-11/27/ :09:01 AM,11/27/ :09:01 AM-11/27/ :09:02 AM $Orig: F19DA18E919452CE872573A0005E3514 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:19 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/27/ :09:02 AM $RespondedTo: 2 Hi I would like to submit a comment about the mexican wolf program, and understand there are guidelines. What are they? Judy Fair

2 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Mon, 26 Nov :12: Received: from p01c11m065.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id 60C7B19E800B for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :38: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO bay0-omc3- s6.bay0.hotmail.com) by p01c11m065.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id 355bb p01c11m065.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <jrob980@msn.com>); Mon, 26 Nov :12: (MST) Received: from hotmail.com ([ ]) by bay0-omc3- s6.bay0.hotmail.com with Microsoft SMTPSVC( ); Mon, 26 Nov :12: Received: from mail pickup service by hotmail.com with Microsoft SMTPSVC; Mon, 26 Nov :12: $MessageID: <BAY117-F36CB6FA46B00BDDAE6EA73E1760@phx.gbl> Received: from by by117fd.bay117.hotmail.msn.com with HTTP; Tue, 27 Nov :12:30 GMT X_Originating_Ip: [ ] X_Originating_ [jrob980@msn.com] X_Sender: jrob980@msn.com From: "JAN ROBERTS" <jrob980@msn.com> SendTo: r2fwe_al@fws.gov Subject: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping PostedDate: 11/26/ :12:30 PM MIME_Version: 1.0 X_OriginalArrivalTime: 27 Nov :12: (UTC) FILETIME=[80CC0BA0:01C830BC] X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.366( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <jrob980@msn.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/26/ :12:36 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:36 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:36 AM SMTPOriginator: jrob980@msn.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/26/ :12:36 PM-11/26/ :12:37 PM,11/26/ :12:37 PM-11/26/ :12:38 PM $Orig: D84403D2CCBF7D A000221CD7 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:15 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/26/ :12:38 PM $RespondedTo: 2 Mr. Brian Milsap, tate Administrator US Fish and Wiidlife Service Sir:

3 I am writing to comment on the proposed rule changes that will determine the Mexican gray wolves future--or not. The rule update is long overdue, but should not include "poison-pill" provisions to sbotage their recovery. Scientists have made many recommendations you have failed to act on, starting in They warned then if recommendations were not followed the wolf population would suffer. The wolves have important and far reaching impacts on the ecosystem in their surroundings. They affect grazing, plant life and other animal life in their area. Rules need updating to protect and help the wolf population thrive. They are at half of what the EIS projected. It's time to step up and do the job right. It is Fish and Wildlife, not Big Business and Ranchers. Ten years is too long to put this off. Jan Roberts 804 E Clubhouse Queen Creek, AZ 85242

4 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Mon, 26 Nov :34: Received: from p01c11m015.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id 5B4CC19E800B for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :59: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO mailgate6.nau.edu) by p01c11m015.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id d4cab p01c11m015.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <aja75@nau.edu>); Mon, 26 Nov :34: (MST) Received: from localhost (localhost.localdomain [ ]) by mailgate6.nau.edu (Postfix) with ESMTP id C5C B for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :34: (MST) X_Virus_Scanned: amavisd-new at nau.edu Received: from mailgate6.nau.edu ([ ]) by localhost (mailgate6.nau.edu [ ]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id X8AhX for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :34: (MST) Received: from webmail.nau.edu (boxwood.ucc.nau.edu [ ]) by mailgate6.nau.edu (Postfix) with ESMTP id A3F B for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :34: (MST) X_WebMail_UserID: aja75@dana.ucc.nau.edu PostedDate: 11/26/ :33:46 PM From: aja75 <aja75@nau.edu> Principal: aja75 <aja75@nau.edu> SendTo: R2FWE_AL@fws.gov X_EXP32_SerialNo: Subject: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping $MessageID: <4756DC96@webmail.nau.edu> MIME_Version: 1.0 $Mailer: Infinite Mobile Delivery (Hydra) SMTP v X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.065( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.183( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <aja75@nau.edu> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/26/ :34:05 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:36 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:36 AM SMTPOriginator: aja75@nau.edu RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/26/ :34:05 PM-11/26/ :34:07 PM,11/26/ :34:07 PM-11/26/ :34:07 PM $Orig: 8148CCCA498C7BBF872573A0001E9644 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:14 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/26/ :34:07 PM $RespondedTo: 2 Hello, I am ing to express my support for the re-establishment project of

5 Mexican Gray Wolves to NM and AZ. As apex predators in these ecosystems, the wolves have a profound impact on all other animals in the area. Re-establishing the wolf population will begin to restore some of the profound impacts that humans have made on this landscape. Thank you for your efforts. Anthony Arena 101 S Agassiz St APT 3 Flagstaff, AZ 86001

6 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Mon, 26 Nov :19: Received: from p01c11m084.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id D290E19E8035 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :45: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO mailgate5.nau.edu) by p01c11m084.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id 9ea9b p01c11m084.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <kas263@nau.edu>); Mon, 26 Nov :19: (MST) Received: from localhost (localhost.localdomain [ ]) by mailgate5.nau.edu (Postfix) with ESMTP id ECBF96B444A for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :19: (MST) X_Virus_Scanned: amavisd-new at nau.edu Received: from mailgate5.nau.edu ([ ]) by localhost (mailgate5.nau.edu [ ]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id 9QXb+jiiIIHx for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :19: (MST) Received: from webmail.nau.edu (boxwood.ucc.nau.edu [ ]) by mailgate5.nau.edu (Postfix) with ESMTP id C9DB56B4004 for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :19: (MST) X_WebMail_UserID: kas263@dana.ucc.nau.edu PostedDate: 11/26/ :19:35 PM From: kas263 <kas263@nau.edu> Principal: kas263 <kas263@nau.edu> SendTo: R2FWE_AL@fws.gov X_EXP32_SerialNo: Subject: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping $MessageID: <47568A2B@webmail.nau.edu> MIME_Version: 1.0 $Mailer: Infinite Mobile Delivery (Hydra) SMTP v X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.244( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.177( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <kas263@nau.edu> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/26/ :19:53 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:36 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:36 AM SMTPOriginator: kas263@nau.edu RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/26/ :19:53 PM-11/26/ :19:54 PM,11/26/ :19:55 PM-11/26/ :19:56 PM $Orig: 2A542E31384AFD A00017CB56 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:12 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/26/ :19:56 PM $RespondedTo: 2 Hello,

7 I strongly support the reintroduction program. We have already seen the positive affects of wolf reintroduction in the Yellowstone ecosystem and it is reasonable to expect there to be ecological benefits here in the southwest. In a time when so many factors are negatively impacting our wildlands, we really should support programs that make positive contributions to ecosystem health. Thank you for your efforts! Ken Sterling kas263@nau.edu

8 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Mon, 26 Nov :16: Received: from p01c11m072.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id E784019E800B for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :41: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO mailgate5.nau.edu) by p01c11m072.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id fdf6b p01c11m072.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <stefan.sommer@nau.edu>); Mon, 26 Nov :16: (MST) Received: from localhost (localhost.localdomain [ ]) by mailgate5.nau.edu (Postfix) with ESMTP id B42C5 for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :16: (MST) X_Virus_Scanned: amavisd-new at nau.edu Received: from mailgate5.nau.edu ([ ]) by localhost (mailgate5.nau.edu [ ]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id M7EWilf+tEMI for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :16: (MST) Received: from [ ] (bio297.bio.nau.edu [ ]) by mailgate5.nau.edu (Postfix) with ESMTP id B4022 for <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :16: (MST) $MessageID: <474B6FCE @nau.edu> PostedDate: 11/26/ :15:58 PM From: Stefan Sommer <Stefan.Sommer@nau.edu> ReplyTo: Stefan.Sommer@nau.edu Organization: Northern Arizona University User_Agent: Thunderbird (Windows/ ) MIME_Version: 1.0 SendTo: R2FWE_AL@fws.gov Subject: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.178( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <stefan.sommer@nau.edu> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/26/ :16:16 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:36 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:36 AM SMTPOriginator: stefan.sommer@nau.edu RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/26/ :16:16 PM-11/26/ :19:01 PM,11/26/ :19:02 PM-11/26/ :19:03 PM $Orig: 7937D602478B456F872573A00006FB80 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:10 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/26/ :19:03 PM $RespondedTo: 2 Dear USFWS, I am writing to encourage you to do everything you can to reintroduce Mexican Gray wolves to their natural habitat in Arizona and New Mexico.

9 These top predators are a critical part of proper ecosystem function, and their extirpation has had cascading effects throughout multiple trophic levels. In my opinion the return of wolves to Arizona and New Mexico will benefit wildlife, promote ecosystem health, and provide the human communities with an important part of our lost legacy. It is something that is long overdue. Sincerely, Stefan Sommer Dr. Stefan Sommer Executive Producer, A River Reborn, Director of Education, Merriam-Powell Center, Vice President, Association of College and University Museums and Galleries, Faculty, Dept. of Biological Sciences Northern Arizona University Campus Box 5640 Flagstaff, AZ Office: (928) FAX: (928) Stefan.Sommer@NAU.EDU

10 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Mon, 26 Nov :03: Received: from p01c11m073.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id E7A6B19E800B for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :28: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO bay0-omc2- s22.bay0.hotmail.com) by p01c11m073.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id 5a05b p01c11m073.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <cpiszczek@msn.com>); Mon, 26 Nov :03: (MST) Received: from hotmail.com ([ ]) by bay0-omc2- s22.bay0.hotmail.com with Microsoft SMTPSVC( ); Mon, 26 Nov :03: Received: from mail pickup service by hotmail.com with Microsoft SMTPSVC; Mon, 26 Nov :03: $MessageID: <BLU109-DAV3DF78F970DDDF3DAB349EA1750@phx.gbl> Received: from by BLU109-DAV3.phx.gbl with DAV; Mon, 26 Nov :02: X_Originating_Ip: [ ] X_Originating_ [cpiszczek@msn.com] X_Sender: cpiszczek@msn.com From: "Carole Piszczek-Sheffield" <cpiszczek@msn.com> SendTo: <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov> Subject: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping PostedDate: 11/26/ :02:51 PM MIME_Version: 1.0 DeliveryPriority: N X_MSMail_Priority: Normal $Mailer: MSN 9 X_MimeOLE: Produced By MSN MimeOLE V Seal_Send_Time: Mon, 26 Nov :02: X_OriginalArrivalTime: 26 Nov :03: (UTC) FILETIME=[7E33A4C0:01C83080] X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.311( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <cpiszczek@msn.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/26/ :03:02 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:37 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:37 AM SMTPOriginator: cpiszczek@msn.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/26/ :03:02 PM-11/26/ :03:03 PM,11/26/ :03:03 PM-11/26/ :03:04 PM $Orig: 514D70DA1DE F007E9F0E Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:08 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/26/ :03:04 PM $RespondedTo: 2

11 To Whom it May Concern: I am writing regarding the Blue Range Wolf Recovery Act (BRWRA) because I am concerned that the number of wolves who are successfully surviving within the designated area appear to be going down rather than stabilizing or growing. I believe that wolves are an integral part of the wildlife chain and wolf populations need not only protection but encouragement to grow. The system as currently designed has several flaws that prevent that from happening: The classification of BRWRA wolves as "experimental, non-essential" must be amended to "experimental, essential (or endangered") in order for this program to succeed to its full potential. Like other valued natural entities -- air, water, bison, bald eagles -- wolves do not understand human created political boundaries. Rather, they follow instinctual beckonings, moving into areas that promise better food resources, habitat, or mating and territorial possibilities. Trying to restrict wolf movement to "approved" areas shows little understanding of how Nature and its denizens function. Wolves require large territories for healthy populations to survive or thrive. Please consider removing restrictions to wolf dispersal and movement. Healthy wildlife populations seldom occur without access to other populations outside their own range. Releasing Gray Wolves in areas outside the BRWRA will provide opportunities for more robust genetic opportunities for the struggling Gray Wolf populations and decrease the possibility of inbred disease, etc. Please consider releasing Gray Wolves in New Mexico to encourage strengthening of the species. Killing wolves while promoting their return doesn't make sense. How can wolves hope to thrive if we keep reducing the number of wolves available for breeding? This is senseless and has to stop. Likewise, putting a cap on the total number of wolves makes no sense for the same reasons. Make ranchers responsible for cleaning up carcasses of their cattle that have died as the result of disease, starvation, or injury. Leaving dead cattle lie on public land only encourages wolves to "get a taste for" beef and jeopardizes healthy cattle and their young. Opportunistic scavenging

12 wolves eat what's available. Ranchers' practices of leaving dead cattle lie only encourages such scavenging. Lastly, please consider leaving options open for future recovery strategies. Wolf recovery is like a living document and needs to remain flexible in order to make the best of this rare opportunity to bring a valuable endangered species back to full recovery. Thank you for the opportunity to express my concerns and opinions. Sincerely, Carole Piszczek-Sheffield PO Box 4388 Sedona, AZ (928) cpiszczek@msn.com

13 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Mon, 26 Nov :21: Received: from p01c11m022.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id 56B3919E8010 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :46: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO s400.sureserver.com) by p01c11m022.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) over TLS secured channel with ESMTP id fb83b p01c11m022.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <brian@ecologicalgenetics.com>); Mon, 26 Nov :21: (MST) Received: (qmail 7542 invoked by uid 504); 26 Nov :21: Received: from unknown (HELO cm flagstaff.az.npgco.com) (brian@ ) by ns1.s400.sureserver.com with ESMTPA; 26 Nov :21: $MessageID: <474B38C @ecologicalgenetics.com> PostedDate: 11/26/ :21:10 PM From: "Brian L. Cardall" <brian@ecologicalgenetics.com> User_Agent: Thunderbird (Macintosh/ ) MIME_Version: 1.0 SendTo: R2FWE_AL@fws.gov Subject: wolf reintroduction X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.479( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.600( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <brian@ecologicalgenetics.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [(unknown)] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/26/ :21:04 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:37 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:37 AM SMTPOriginator: brian@ecologicalgenetics.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/26/ :21:04 PM-11/26/ :21:05 PM,11/26/ :21:05 PM-11/26/ :21:06 PM $Orig: F88A0C439E6B7E F Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:06 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/26/ :21:06 PM $RespondedTo: 2 Dear USFWS, I simply wanted to state my support for wolf reintroduction in Arizona. Apex predators provide an integral component of proper ecosystem function, and their extirpation has had cascading effects throughout multiple trophic levels (the classic example is the Kaibab deer population). In my opinion the return of wolves to Arizona will benefit wildlife and promote ecosystem health. It is something that is long overdue. Sincerely,

14 Brian Cardall Brian L. Cardall, MS Science Foundation of Arizona Fellow Department of Biological Sciences Northern Arizona University Flagstaff, AZ, (435)

15 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Mon, 26 Nov :52: Received: from p01c11m093.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id C4EEA19E8010 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Mon, 26 Nov :18: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO stan.its.monash.edu.au) by p01c11m093.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id ff32b p01c11m093.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <faith.walker@sci.monash.edu.au>); Mon, 26 Nov :52: (MST) Received: from larry.its.monash.edu.au ([ ]) by stan.its.monash.edu.au (Sun Java System Messaging Server (built Sep )) with ESMTP id <0JS400B6YPVI9A30@stan.its.monash.edu.au> for r2fwe_al@fws.gov; Tue, 27 Nov :52: (EST) Received: from larry.its.monash.edu.au (localhost.localdomain [ ]) by localhost (Postfix) with SMTP id 72B4C80003 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Tue, 27 Nov :52: (EST) Received: from monash.edu.au (dollet.its.monash.edu.au [ ]) by larry.its.monash.edu.au (Postfix) with ESMTP id C004 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Tue, 27 Nov :52: (EST) Received: from [ ] by mail-store-2.its.monash.edu.au (mshttpd) ; Mon, 26 Nov :52: PostedDate: 11/26/ :52:29 PM From: Faith Walker <Faith.Walker@sci.monash.edu.au> Subject: Attn: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping SendTo: r2fwe_al@fws.gov $MessageID: <fc7e94092dbf2.2dbf2fc7e9409@monash.edu.au> MIME_Version: 1.0 $Mailer: iplanet Messenger Express 5.2 HotFix 2.12 (built May ) X_Accept_Language: en Priority: normal X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.093( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.633( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <faith.walker@sci.monash.edu.au> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/26/ :52:32 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:37 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:37 AM SMTPOriginator: faith.walker@sci.monash.edu.au RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/26/ :52:32 PM-11/26/ :52:33 PM,11/26/ :52:34 PM-11/26/ :52:34 PM $Orig: C5413C41EA55E F006D2E30 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:04 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/26/ :52:34 PM $RespondedTo: 2

16 Dear Mr. Millsap, Please consider these comments for Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping. I will be attending tonite's meeting in Flagstaff, AZ, but prefer to submit my comments via . I am a wildlife biologist with extensive experience working with endangered mammals, and would like to see the following in relation to the Mexican Gray Wolf reintroduction project: 1. An updated recovery plan, with very specific objectives regarding number of wolves defining recovery, and no maximum number. 2. A change in wolf status to "endangered", or "experimental, essential". 3. Expansion of acceptable wolf boundary, as well as increased area for initial releases. 4. Non-lethal resolution of wolf-livestock conflicts, in a way that adequately compensates livestock owners. 5. Decreased "take" of wolves. and 6. Increased emphasis on genetic diversity of wolf population. Thank you for your consideration, Dr. Faith Walker 2700 Woodlands Village Blvd. Ste Flagstaff, AZ 86001

17 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sun, 25 Nov :19: Received: from p01c11m002.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id 7B83919E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :45: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO fed1rmmtao106.cox.net) by p01c11m002.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id f694a p01c11m002.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <jgaz1@cox.net>); Sun, 25 Nov :19: (MST) Received: from fed1rmimpo01.cox.net ([ ]) by fed1rmmtao106.cox.net (InterMail vm ) with ESMTP id < SBCV20016.fed1rmmtao106.cox.net@fed1rmimpo01.cox.net> for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :19: Received: from fed1wml06.mgt.cox.net ([ ]) by fed1rmimpo01.cox.net with bizsmtp id HGKy1Y0080DrMWL ; Sun, 25 Nov :19: Received: from by webmail.west.cox.net; Sun, 25 Nov :19: $MessageID: < OSR3D root@fed1wml06.mgt.cox.net> PostedDate: 11/25/ :19:58 PM From: <jgaz1@cox.net> SendTo: r2fwe_al@fws.gov Subject: Attn: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping MIME_Version: 1.0 DeliveryPriority: N $KeepPrivate: 0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.169( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <jgaz1@cox.net> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/25/ :19:59 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:37 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:37 AM SMTPOriginator: jgaz1@cox.net RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/25/ :19:59 PM-11/25/ :20:00 PM,11/25/ :20:00 PM-11/25/ :20:01 PM $Orig: C B8BCFE F0017CDA0 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:02 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/25/ :20:01 PM $RespondedTo: 2 Brian Millsap State Administrator U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service New Mexico Ecological Services Field Office 2105 Osuna NE Albuquerque, NM 87113

18 Dear Mr. Millsap, I would like to express my thoughts on the Mexican Gray Wolf Recovery program. I am a strong advocate for the reintroduction of the Mexican Gray Wolf into its former habitat. The issues I saw on the website seem to revolve around a few main concerns. 1) Range: The wolves seem to do alright when they are not shot by poachers. Therefore, I would like to see them reintroduced in other parts of the Experimental Population Area Boundary, initially near the existing packs. Perhaps reintroductions could be done over time in concentric circles farther and farther from the BRWRA, with the eventual goal of the wolves occupying as much of the Experimental Population Area Boundary as natural prey and available land allows. Based on the historic range, they could either be reintroduced or migrate to other areas north of I-40 and south of I-10 if prey is available-north of Flagstaff and north of Santa Fe, into the mountains of Northern NM. 2) Pet Attacks by Wolves: I don't believe wolves that have attacked pets should be removed. People need to keep their pets close by, not wandering wherever they please. 3) Livestock Attacks by Wolves: These wolves should be removed if they are repeat offenders. Preferably not shot, but captured. In closing-please greatly increase the allowable range/reintroductions and maintain protection for the Mexican Gray Wolf so that they can reoccupy as much of their former habitat as prey and available land allow. Thank you for your assistance in this matter. -James Graham James Graham S. 47th Street Phoenix, AZ 85044

19 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sun, 25 Nov :50: Received: from p01c11m091.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id BC86319E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :15: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO mtiwmhc12.worldnet.att.net) by p01c11m091.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id 7824a p01c11m091.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <r.a.calabro@att.net>); Sun, 25 Nov :50: (MST) Received: from calabror (28.phoenix-11rh16rt.az.dialaccess.att.net[ ]) by worldnet.att.net (mtiwmhc12) with SMTP id < lv0nte>; Mon, 26 Nov :50: $MessageID: <004f01c82fdf$4e370420$1c77480c@ID.CITISTREET.ORG> ReplyTo: "Richard Calabro" <r.a.calabro@att.net> From: "Richard Calabro" <r.a.calabro@att.net> SendTo: <r2fwe_al@fws.gov> Subject: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping. PostedDate: 11/25/ :49:09 PM MIME_Version: 1.0 DeliveryPriority: N X_MSMail_Priority: Normal $Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express X_MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.041( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.024( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <r.a.calabro@att.net> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/25/ :50:32 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:38 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:38 AM SMTPOriginator: r.a.calabro@att.net RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/25/ :50:32 PM-11/25/ :50:33 PM,11/25/ :50:33 PM-11/25/ :50:34 PM $Orig: E0581C534D890D F00151B43 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :19:01 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/25/ :50:34 PM $RespondedTo: 2 Brian Millsap, State Administrator U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service New Mexico Ecological Services Field Office 2105 Osuna NE Albuquerque, NM Attn: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping

20 Mexican gray wolves are critical to our natural environment. A healthy wolf population will keep our elk and deer herds healthy and bring balance back to our wildlands. Please correct the mistakes of the past and ensure a bright future for wolf recovery. While reintroduced wolves have thrived in the Northern Rockies - now numbering over 1,500 - the Mexican gray wolf population remains dangerously low, with only about 60 wolves in an area twice the size of Yellowstone. The difference is in the rules governing the program. Because of these rules, 11 wolves have been shot by the government, 20 more died inadvertently because of capture, and at least 24 have been trapped and permanently removed from the wild since the reintroduction began. Northern Rockieswolves are allowed to expand their territory. Mexican gray wolves are confined to the Blue Range Wolf Recovery Area, which includes the GilaNational Forestin New Mexicoand the bordering Apache National Forestin Arizona. But with good habitat outside of these areas, wolves often cross the political lines in search off new homes and prey. When they choose to live outside the boundaries they are captured and returned to the Blue range. This thwarts expansion of the population, disrupts packs, and sometimes causes serious injury to individual wolves. Current rules do not require ranchers using public lands to remove or render inedible (as by lime, for example) the carcasses of livestock that die for a number of non-wolf related reasons like disease and starvation. Wolves are attracted to and often scavenge on these carcasses, and then begin to prey on live cattle or horses nearby. After three livestock kills in a year, the wolf is either killed or placed in captivity. The gray wolf reintroduction rule for the northern Rocky Mountains in YellowstoneNational Parkand central Idahorequired ranchers to remove such attractants and specified that wolves that prey on stock near to where they were drawn by carcasses would not be controlled. But the Mexican wolf never received this protection. Please change the rule to save the wolves. Richard A. Calabro 3055 S. Placita Del Avestruz Green Valley, AZ Tel Fax r.a.calabro@att.net

21 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sun, 25 Nov :14: Received: from p01c11m091.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id CF13C19E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :39: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO elasmtpmasked.atl.sa.earthlink.net) by p01c11m091.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id cdd1a p01c11m091.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <threshld@mindspring.com>); Sun, 25 Nov :14: (MST) DomainKey_Signature: a=rsa-sha1; q=dns; c=nofws; s=dk ; d=mindspring.com; b=zfd0m+xzqglrwuwdxhdt87jsyven5v8hztpumk1horoc5stczy66k223a2ly1ccn; h=received:message-id:from:to:subject:date:mime-version:content-type:x- Priority:X-MSMail-Priority:X-Mailer:X-MimeOLE:X-ELNK-Trace:X- Originating-IP; Received: from [ ] (helo=dsteele) by elasmtpmasked.atl.sa.earthlink.net with asmtp (Exim 4.34) id 1IwSXz-0005cR- D0 for r2fwe_al@fws.gov; Sun, 25 Nov :14: $MessageID: <001001c82fca$a8aabc40$7227f004@DSteele> From: "Donna Steele" <Threshld@mindspring.com> SendTo: <r2fwe_al@fws.gov> Subject: Attn Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping PostedDate: 11/25/ :19:03 PM MIME_Version: 1.0 DeliveryPriority: N X_MSMail_Priority: Normal $Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express X_MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V X_ELNK_Trace: b6d30e94d615536e9c7f779228e2f6aeda e20db4d a78ce7abcb5f5116 d815b8da0350badd9bab72f9c350badd9bab72f9c350badd9bab72f9c X_Originating_Ip: X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.103( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <threshld@mindspring.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/25/ :14:05 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:38 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:38 AM SMTPOriginator: threshld@mindspring.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/25/ :14:05 PM-11/25/ :14:06 PM,11/25/ :14:06 PM-11/25/ :14:06 PM $Orig: 7E6CD9E4364BA F0006C861 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :18:58 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/25/ :14:06 PM $RespondedTo: 2

22 WOLVES BELONG IN ARIZONA! As a concerned citizen of Arizona for the past 24 years, I'm writing to urge Fish and Wildlife to correct the mistakes of the past and ensure Mexican gray wolves continue to be protected. Science has shown FOR YEARS that top predator health in any wildlife eco-system ENSURES the health of that eco-system. Don't cave to irrational myths and fears or that have taken over the government during the special interest groups Bush administration. Please do the responsible thing for wildlife. for wolf recovery in Arizona. Ensure a bright future Respectfully, Donna L. Steele 1524 N. Sunset Drive Flagstaff, AZ

23 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sun, 25 Nov :28: Received: from p01c11m001.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id EE48019E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :53: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO bay0-omc3- s25.bay0.hotmail.com) by p01c11m001.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id f231a p01c11m001.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <csteiner5@msn.com>); Sun, 25 Nov :28: (MST) Received: from hotmail.com ([ ]) by bay0-omc3- s25.bay0.hotmail.com with Microsoft SMTPSVC( ); Sun, 25 Nov :28: Received: from mail pickup service by hotmail.com with Microsoft SMTPSVC; Sun, 25 Nov :28: $MessageID: <BLU116-DAV14C58D9025F9E4EEB0C948E1750@phx.gbl> Received: from by BLU116-DAV14.phx.gbl with DAV; Mon, 26 Nov :28: X_Originating_Ip: [ ] X_Originating_ [csteiner5@msn.com] X_Sender: csteiner5@msn.com From: "Christine Steiner" <csteiner5@msn.com> SendTo: <r2fwe_al@fws.gov> Subject: Attn:Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping PostedDate: 11/25/ :28:28 PM MIME_Version: 1.0 DeliveryPriority: N X_MSMail_Priority: Normal $Mailer: MSN 9 X_MimeOLE: Produced By MSN MimeOLE V Seal_Send_Time: Sun, 25 Nov :28: X_OriginalArrivalTime: 26 Nov :28: (UTC) FILETIME=[45248A90:01C82FC3] X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.351( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <csteiner5@msn.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/25/ :28:31 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:38 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:38 AM SMTPOriginator: csteiner5@msn.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/25/ :28:31 PM-11/25/ :28:32 PM,11/25/ :28:32 PM-11/25/ :28:33 PM $Orig: 5E95F7147D809C F00029CA6 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :18:56 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/25/ :28:33 PM $RespondedTo: 2

24 TO: Brian Millsap, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service: I would like to state that I am a supporter of the wolf recovery program in New Mexico, but will not be able to attend the scheduled hearings. Thank you. Mary Christine Steiner 5 San Felipe Tr. NW Corrales, NM 87048

25 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sun, 25 Nov :38: Received: from p01c11m021.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id 90BFD19E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :04: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (HELO outboundmail.dca.untd.com) by p01c11m021.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with SMTP id 36dd p01c11m021.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <zamboni999@netzero.net>); Sun, 25 Nov :38: (MST) Received: from Budd (dialup dial1.phoenix1.level3.net [ ]) by smtpout05.vgs.untd.com with SMTP id AABDWVZL9ADWQ242 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov> (sender <zamboni999@netzero.net>); Sun, 25 Nov :38: (PDT) From: "zamboni999" <zamboni999@netzero.com> SendTo: <r2fwe_al@fws.gov> Subject: Mexican Grey Wolf NEPA Scoping PostedDate: 11/25/ :38:56 PM $MessageID: <000001c82fa3$ $9d8a2d20$@com> MIME_Version: 1.0 $Mailer: Microsoft Office Outlook 12.0 thread_index: AcgvozHlii43FankRfGd9eItvd4tjA== X_ContentStamp: 6:3: X_MAIL_INFO: 5cb cd bccd75755c0d01787dfc2de51dadbd0045a53ce1a5bd99d9bdb a5f9b8a5e1c1f168f115d8e8c5ace89c5d1c25ac9c c9b5ecc1b1e9c8 71dcfcf168794d61f845715d69691d8d785c11b5e5688c696c6c8c3175b9f5d50d4529e c650831cc6d65 X_UNTD_OriginStamp: dai6a8ejecpywfb+/yfpuqwisjgat2m+gygdns/k+cut/b3rdztz5lk8pa8gxvjw X_UNTD_Peer_Info: smtpout05.vgs.untd.com smtpout05.vgs.untd.com zamboni999@n etzero.net X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.067( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <zamboni999@netzero.net> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/25/ :38:59 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:39 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:39 AM SMTPOriginator: zamboni999@netzero.net RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/25/ :38:59 PM-11/25/ :39:00 PM,11/25/ :39:00 PM-11/25/ :39:01 PM $Orig: EEB636A2FDF4181C E00716F09 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :18:55 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/25/ :39:01 PM $RespondedTo: 2

26 Dear Mr. Millsap, I urge you to correct past mistakes in the wolf recovery program, and ensure that the Mexican Grey wolf is properly reintroduced to it s native New Mexico. Our ecosystem is not complete without the wolf. We need wolves look at the improvement of Yellowstone since wolves were successfully re-introduced there. The same will happen here in New Mexico. I understand the concerns of the few ranchers involved. Let s help them protect their animals or give them other assistance they need. But the wolf must return for everyone s sake. Thank you, Budd Berkman 11 Canoncito Rd. Placitas, NM Zamboni999@netzero.com

27 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sun, 25 Nov :42: Received: from p01c11m023.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id C490219E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :08: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO smtpoutm.mac.com) by p01c11m023.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id f22c p01c11m023.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <joelle9@mac.com>); Sun, 25 Nov :42: (MST) Received: from mac.com (asmtp002-s [ ]) by smtpoutm.mac.com (Xserve/smtpout009/MantshX 4.0) with ESMTP id lapigtuy for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :42: (PST) Received: from [ ] ( qdsl.olypen.com [ ]) (authenticated bits=0) by mac.com (Xserve/asmtp002/MantshX 4.0) with ESMTP id lapigssa for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :42: (PST) MIME_Version: 1.0 (Apple Message framework v624) $MessageID: <0778d5866c7a629d80b9d445982b0612@mac.com> SendTo: r2fwe_al@fws.gov From: Joan <joelle9@mac.com> Subject: Mexican Grey Wolf PostedDate: 11/25/ :42:38 AM $Mailer: Apple Mail (2.624) X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.145( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <joelle9@mac.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/25/ :42:56 AM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:39 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:39 AM SMTPOriginator: joelle9@mac.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/25/ :42:56 AM-11/25/ :42:57 AM,11/25/ :42:57 AM-11/25/ :42:58 AM $Orig: BAD E0066CEED Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :18:53 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/25/ :42:58 AM $RespondedTo: 2 Please rethink the extermination or culling of grey wolves. Nature provides a balance which doesn't include man in assisting it. Thank You, J. Owen P.O. Box Pt. Ludlow, WA 98365

28

29 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sun, 25 Nov :51: Received: from p01c11m073.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id E384C19E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sun, 25 Nov :16: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO smtpauth13.mail.atl.earthlink.net) by p01c11m073.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id 5f7a p01c11m073.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <ddobson@peoplepc.com>); Sun, 25 Nov :51: (MST) Received: from [ ] (helo=office) by smtpauth13.mail.atl.earthlink.net with asmtp (Exim 4.34) id 1IwKhA- 0001z5-NA for r2fwe_al@fws.gov; Sun, 25 Nov :51: $MessageID: <000f01c82f83$2e8d1bc0$0200a8c0@OFFICE> From: "Deborah Dobson" <ddobson@peoplepc.com> SendTo: <r2fwe_al@fws.gov> Subject: ATTN: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping PostedDate: 11/25/ :49:43 AM MIME_Version: 1.0 DeliveryPriority: N X_MSMail_Priority: Normal $Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express X_MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V X_ELNK_Trace: d6e0d00045d169bfe43089e13f4d3dcca4beb055f130b31a5f0f528785fa7f3c7ce263a 2606de90c350badd9bab72f9c350badd9bab72f9c350badd9bab72f9c X_Originating_Ip: X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); S=0.649( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.432( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <ddobson@peoplepc.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/25/ :51:01 AM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:39 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:39 AM SMTPOriginator: ddobson@peoplepc.com RoutingState: $UpdatedBy:,CN=IFW9BCT-SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteServers: CN=IFW9BCT- SMTP1/OU=FWS/O=DOI,CN=FW2ROMAIL/OU=R2/OU=FWS/O=DOI RouteTimes: 11/25/ :51:01 AM-11/25/ :51:02 AM,11/25/ :51:02 AM-11/25/ :51:03 AM $Orig: 98FBE3D43D976AA E005C9009 Categories: $Revisions: 01/04/ :18:51 AM $MsgTrackFlags: 0 DeliveredDate: 11/25/ :51:03 AM $RespondedTo: 2 Dear Mr. Millsap, At the risk of sounding like a tree-hugger, I want to add my pro-wolf comments to the mix.

30 The more we humans interfere with the balance of nature, the worse it gets. We have our agendas - we need to graze our livestock, we "need" to have animals to hunt, etc. But the bottom line is that wolves, like every other living creature, are a part of the bigger picture and like it or not, they are a vital part of the ecosystem in which we all need to live. Why can't we all coexist harmoniously and respectfully share this beautiful space we call home? Sincerely, Deborah Dobson 4023 E. Comanche Drive Cottonwood, AZ 86326

31 Received: from smtp1.fws.gov ([ ]) by ifw9bctsmtp1.fws.doi.net (Lotus Domino Release 7.0.3) with ESMTP id ; Sat, 24 Nov :43: Received: from p01c11m084.mxlogic.net (mxl144v247.mxlogic.net [ ]) by smtp1.fws.gov (Postfix) with ESMTP id 7B25A19E8008 for <r2fwe_al@fws.gov>; Sat, 24 Nov :08: (MST) Received: from unknown [ ] (EHLO mailout12.yourhostingaccount.com) by p01c11m084.mxlogic.net (mxl_mta ) with ESMTP id 619a p01c11m084.mxlogic.net (envelope-from <srs0=sb6mgx=qr=gilaranchers.fatcow.com=laura@yourhostingaccount.com>); Sat, 24 Nov :43: (MST) Received: from mailscan19.yourhostingaccount.com ([ ] helo=mailscan19.yourhostingaccount.com) by mailout12.yourhostingaccount.com with esmtp (Exim) id 1Iw3in-00064j- Ba for r2fwe_al@fws.gov; Sat, 24 Nov :43: Received: from impout03.yourhostingaccount.com ([ ] helo=impout03.yourhostingaccount.com) by mailscan19.yourhostingaccount.com with esmtp (Exim) id 1Iw3in-0001Kk- 0L for r2fwe_al@fws.gov; Sat, 24 Nov :43: Received: from authsmtp05.yourhostingaccount.com ([ ]) by impout03.yourhostingaccount.com with NO UCE id GmjY1Y00F06ZpSa ; Sat, 24 Nov :43: X_EN_OrigOutIP: X_EN_IMPSID: GmjY1Y00F06ZpSa Received: from cust.wildblue.net ([ ] helo=rsreeffb226c30) by authsmtp05.yourhostingaccount.com with esmtpa (Exim) id 1Iw3ik-00011t-Ih for R2FWE_AL@fws.gov; Sat, 24 Nov :43: Principal: "GLGA" <Laura@gilaranchers.fatcow.com> SendTo: <R2FWE_AL@fws.gov> Subject: Mexican Gray Wolf NEPA Scoping PostedDate: 11/24/ :43:16 PM MIME_Version: 1.0 $Mailer: Microsoft Office Outlook, Build X_MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V thread_index: Acgu88kkO3AxYtB2SNaiCC9B/5E3ow== X_EN_UserInfo: ef649fe74e2e96246d0738bf973dccb7:7f163c65c8eab64f658b a64 X_EN_AuthUser: Laura@gilaranchers.fatcow.com From: "GLGA" <Laura@gilaranchers.fatcow.com> X_EN_OrigIP: X_EN_OrigHost: cust.wildblue.net X_Processed_By: Rebuild v2.0-0 X_Spam: [F= ; B=0.500(0); spf=0.500; S=0.010( ); MH=0.500( ); R=0.130( ); SC=none; SS=0.500] X_Mail_From: <srs0=sb6mgx=qr=gilaranchers.fatcow.com=laura@yourhostingaccount.com> X_SOURCE_IP: [ ] $MessageID: < B25A19E8008@smtp1.fws.gov> $MIMETrack: Itemize by SMTP Server on IFW9BCT-SMTP1/FWS/DOI(Release September 26, 2007) at 11/24/ :43:34 PM,MIME-CD by Notes Client on Magdalena Etemadi/R2/FWS/DOI(Release January 21, 2004) at 01/23/ :03:39 AM,MIME-CD complete at 01/23/ :03:39 AM SMTPOriginator: srs0=sb6mgx=qr=gilaranchers.fatcow.com=laura@yourhostingaccount.com