Animal Cruelty Investigations: Evidence Of Animal Crimes

Transcription

1 Animal Cruelty Investigations: Evidence 2015 Tennessee Animal Care & Control Conference Presented by: Kathryn Destreza Director of Investigations Field Investigations and Response ASPCA cell 1 Evidence Of Animal Crimes Determined by the type charges and scene Any type of evidence can be found at any type of scene Collect it or leave it? 2 1

2 Animal Evidence Crime Scene Shelter Chain Of Evidence Transport Medical Exam 3 Animal Evidence Cage/Room/Space is assigned a # prior to the animal being removed or the living conditions changed (adding food/water) 4 2

3 Animal Evidence The animal is documented in the environment Animal is then removed for Intake/Inventory 5 Animal Evidence Each animal is given a unique ID # and tagged with that # One identification picture is taken Photo board used to capture necessary information. 6 3

4 Documentation of Animal Inventory Will be a record of the property removed Genuine # of animals Chain of evidence Animal Evidence 7 Animal Evidence Transport Manifest Records: Every animal placed on vehicle. Origin and the time driver leaves Destination and the time of arrival 8 4

5 Animal Evidence 9 Medical Exams document the degree of abuse. Also provides info for sheltering: General Medical Exam Treatment Outlined Intake Vaccinations Animal Evidence If possible, be available to assist the veterinarian with examination photographs and evidence collection Evidence collection from an animal by the veterinarian may include: Hair mats DNA Nails Photographs Blood, fecal or other biological samples Photographic documentation should also be done of the animals as they progress and change 10 5

6 Deceased Remains Documented as evidence Photographed before altering environment Assigned an evidence # - NOT an intake # Will be on scene sketch Animals deceased at scene, euthanized as a result of their condition or that subsequently die should be sent for necropsy. 11 Deceased Remains Necropsy to determine natural or unnatural death Bone marrow fat testing can be done to assess nutritional condition of deceased animal used in conjunction with other findings to diagnose starvation Bovine and Equine Long bone with least decomposition Less than 48hrs post-mortem preferred up to 60 days post-mortem 12 6

7 Skeletal Remains - Remains analyzed for trauma and disease 13 Deceased Remains Evidence Collection Entomology can be used to help determine postmortem interval Botany can be used to help determine postmortem interval or be examined for possible poisonous plants 14 7

8 Deceased Remains 15 Other Consideration Were any bodies disposed on property? Is the decomposing carcass a health concern for the community or for other animals? Forensic Analysis Most local and state crime laboratories won t accept animal evidence Evidence must go to academic institution or private laboratory 16 8

9 Strength and Endurance 17 Strength and Endurance Chains should be collected and weighed so comparison can be made to body weight of animal carrying it Length should be documented if confinement is an issue 18 9

10 Strength and Endurance 19 Strength and Endurance 20 10

11 Strength and Endurance 21 Breeding 22 11

12 Sparring Paraphernalia 23 Medical: Supplements and Wound Care 24 12

13 Medical: Supplements and Wound Care Photos:Documentall sides of medication and supplement bottles. 25 Weighing Devices 26 13

14 Breaksticks 27 Fighting Paraphernalia 28 14

15 Fighting Pits 29 Fighting Pits 30 15

16 Fighting Pits 31 Fighting Pits 32 16

17 Fighting Pits 33 Blood and Trace Evidence - Phenolphthalein and Hexagon OBTI - DNA testing - Canine CODIS - Hair classification 34 17

18 Blood and Trace Evidence Phenolphthalein 35 Animal Fighting Evidence 36 18

19 Blood and Trace Evidence 37 Phenolphthalein Hexagon OBTI 38 19

20 Documents & Other 39 Documents & Other 40 20

21 Documents & Other 41 Documents & Other 42 21

22 Animals Living conditions - Space - Cleanliness - Comfort 43 Animals 44 22

23 Documenting Scar Evidence Purpose is to show distribution Only fighting scars and/or injuries Ball Point Pen: Blue = healed Red = fresh or healing Doesn t have to be exact number 45 Animals 46 23

24 Animal Remains 47 Hoarding and Puppy Mills Animal Hoarder Person who maintains a higher-than-usual number of animals. Beyond capacity to properly house or care for them Puppy Mill commercial breeding operation Care and health of the animal is often disregarded

25 Living Conditions 49 Amount and quality of food/water Excessive feces/urine Diseased feces/vomit Comfort blanket, newspaper, enrichment, etc. Living Conditions 50 25

26 Living Conditions 51 Living Conditions 52 26

27 Living Conditions Is there adequate amount of food and water? Is it fresh/potable? Is the food appropriate for the age and medical condition of the animals 53 Living Conditions 54 27

28 Hoarding and Puppy Mills General condition of property 55 Veterinary Supplies and Records 56 28

29 Hoarding and Puppy Mills Medication Are supplements present? Are substitute medications present? Labor inducing medications? 57 Hoarding and Puppy Mills Other Documentation Financial Records Solicitation of donations Inappropriate use of donations Registration papers Employee and payroll records (staff count to number of animals) Sale receipts 58 29

30 Crimes beyond animal cruelty Consumer fraud (marketing and selling sick dogs) Environmental crimes (waste) Employee safety (ammonia levels indoors) Unlicensed practice of veterinary medicine Unlawful lottery (marketing trick: win free dog) Tax evasion/fraud Civil nuisance abatement 59 Kathryn Destreza Director of Investigations Field Investigations and Response ASPCA cell 60 30