This article was downloaded by: [Dr Kenneth Shapiro] On: 09 June 2015, At: 10:20 Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/haaw20 Impact of the Economic Recession on Companion Animal Relinquishment, Adoption, and Euthanasia: A Chicago Animal Shelter's Experience Hsin-Yi Weng a & Lynette A. Hart b a Department of Pathobiology, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign b Department of Population Health and Reproduction, University of California, Davis Published online: 10 Jan 2012. To cite this article: Hsin-Yi Weng & Lynette A. Hart (2012) Impact of the Economic Recession on Companion Animal Relinquishment, Adoption, and Euthanasia: A Chicago Animal Shelter's Experience, Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 15:1, 80-90, DOI: 10.1080/10888705.2012.624908 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10888705.2012.624908 PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the Content ) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content. This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
JOURNAL OF APPLIED ANIMAL WELFARE SCIENCE, 15:80 90, 2012 Copyright Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1088-8705 print/1532-7604 online DOI: 10.1080/10888705.2012.624908 Impact of the Economic Recession on Companion Animal Relinquishment, Adoption, and Euthanasia: A Chicago Animal Shelter s Experience Hsin-Yi Weng 1 and Lynette A. Hart 2 1 Department of Pathobiology, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign 2 Department of Population Health and Reproduction, University of California, Davis This study investigated how the current economic recession (since December 2007) has affected dog and cat relinquishment, adoption, and euthanasia at the Anti-Cruelty Society animal shelter in Chicago, Illinois. The study compared temporal patterns of the investigated statistics before (2000 2007) the start of the current recession with the patterns after the start of the recession (2008 2010). The results showed that once the guardianship (ownership) of a nonhuman animal had been established, the recession did not greatly affect the owner s decision on relinquishment except for the relinquishment of senior dogs, which may be associated with increased costs of care. However, an unfavorable economic environment may have reduced adoption of animals. The consequences of a decline in adoptions might be reflected in an increase in the proportion or number of sheltered animals euthanized. This study demonstrated how monitoring changes in temporal patterns in these shelter statistics can help guide animal shelters to better prepare for the current recession. The current economic recession, which began in December 2007 (National Bureau of Economic Research, 2010), affects our communities in many ways. Hsin-Yi Weng is now in the Department of Comparative Pathobiology, School of Veterinary Medicine, Purdue University. Correspondence should be sent to Hsin-Yi Weng, Department of Comparative Pathobiology, School of Veterinary Medicine, Purdue University, 625 Harrison Street, West Lafayette, IN 47907. Email: hweng@ucdavis.edu 80
IMPACT OF THE ECONOMIC RECESSION 81 Companion nonhuman animals, who share a close relationship with humans, are inevitably affected by the recession (Patronek, Beck, & Glickman, 1997; Scarlett, 2008). Although many studies have investigated risk factors for dog and cat relinquishment and factors affecting the success of animal adoption (DiGiacomo, Arluke, & Patronek, 1998; Marston & Bennett, 2003; New et al., 2000; Olson & Moulton, 1993; Patronek, Glickman, Beck, & McCabe, 1996; Patronek, Glickman, Beck, McCabe, & Ecker, 1996; Posage, Bartlett, & Thomas, 1998), the latest study was conducted more than 10 years ago. The economic environment of recession might substantially alter risk factor patterns and their relationships to companion animal overpopulation. More directly, the recession might also reduce the already limited resources for fighting the surplus of companion animals. How animal shelters and nonprofit animal protection organizations prepare for this recession is vital. This adverse economic environment provides researchers with a unique opportunity to address these important issues. In this study, we focused on how the current recession affects the dynamics of animal intake (such as relinquishment) and disposal (such as adoption and euthanasia) at the Anti-Cruelty Society s (ACS) animal shelter in Chicago, Illinois. Specifically, the study was carried out to test the following hypotheses: 1. The numbers of dogs and cats relinquished will increase during the recession period (after 2007). 2. The numbers and proportions of dogs and cats adopted among sheltered animals will decrease during the recession period. 3. The numbers and proportions of dogs and cats euthanized at the participating shelter will increase during the recession period. 4. The economic recession will affect dogs more than cats. MATERIALS AND METHODS This study was conducted at the animal shelter of the ACS in Chicago, Illinois. The ACS animal shelter is one of the largest shelters serving the Chicago metropolitan area and the surrounding neighborhoods in northern Illinois. Because the ACS has been keeping electronic records of all animals brought in and/or housed at the shelter since 1991, this allows the researcher to evaluate the long-term temporal patterns in animal relinquishment, adoption, and euthanasia. In this study, we reviewed and analyzed the ACS shelter records on dog and cat intake and disposal between 2000 and 2010. In particular, we assessed the impact of the current economic recession by comparing the temporal patterns in these measures before and after the start of the recession. In order to include 2010 data in the analysis, only the records between January 1 and September 15 for the 11 years of investigation were evaluated. Holt s exponential smoothing
82 WENG AND HART TABLE 1 Key Words Used to Identify Reporting Cost, Moving or Foreclosure of Home, or Illness of the Nonhuman Animal as the Primary Reason for Relinquishment by the Caregivers (Owners) Who Surrendered Their Animals to the Anti-Cruelty Society Animal Shelter in Chicago, Illinois Primary Reason Cost Moving or foreclosure of home Illness of the animal Keywords Cannot afford, too expensive Losing home, move, foreclosure, leave Health, sick, physical condition, ill, declining health, injury, specified name of diseases method was used to estimate the predicted values (and their 95% confidence limits [CL]) for years 2008 to 2010 (defined as the recession period) by using the data from the prerecession period (2000 to 2007). The observed values during the recession were then compared with these predicted values and their 95% CL. In the ACS database, the age of the animal was classified into the following groups: (a) kitten or puppy (less than 6 months old), (b) adults (from 6 months to less than 8 years old), and (c) seniors (8 years or older). In order to further investigate the impact of the recession, we compared the temporal patterns in reporting cost, moving or foreclosure of home, or illness of the animal as the primary reason for relinquishment before and after the start of the recession. These reasons were believed to be dependent on the caregiver s (owner s) financial status. The information on reporting the primary reason for relinquishment was collected in free text at the ACS shelter. Table 1 summarizes the keywords used to define the primary reason for relinquishment as cost, moving or foreclosure of home, and illness of the animal. RESULTS The projection using the ACS shelter data during the prerecession period (2000 to 2007) showed a steadily decreasing trend in the numbers of puppies and adult dogs relinquished, whereas the projected number of animals relinquished stayed constant across the years for all age categories of cats and senior dogs (Figure 1a, 1b). After comparing the observed data with the projected trend, the number of senior dogs relinquished showed a significant increase in 2009 and 2010 (Figure 1a). The observed numbers of puppies and adult dogs relinquished were also greater than the predicted values during the recession period, although the differences did not surpass the upper 95% CL. Opposite results were observed in the numbers of kittens and adult cats relinquished in 2010, which were lower than the projected values (Figure 1b). After further investigations on whether
IMPACT OF THE ECONOMIC RECESSION 83 (a) (b) FIGURE 1 Temporal patterns in the numbers of dogs and cats relinquished to the Anti- Cruelty Society Animal Shelter (Chicago, Illinois) between January 1 and September 15 of each year from 2000 to 2010. The dashed lines are the predicted values estimated by the data from 2000 to 2007 using Holt s exponential smoothing method. C indicates the observed value is above the 95% upper limit for the predicted value and * indicates the observed value is below the 95% lower limit for the predicted value. Puppy or Kitten: less than 6 months old; Adult: from 6 months to less than 8 years old; Senior: 8 years or older. there was a change in the patterns of reporting cost, moving or foreclosure of home, or illness as the primary reason for relinquishment before and after the start of the recession, cost was the only one showing a significant difference from the predicted values (Figure 2). Temporal patterns in the numbers of senior dogs, kittens, and adult cats adopted showed significant differences before and after the start of the recession (Figure 3a, 3b). A more consistent decrease was observed in the adoption of
84 WENG AND HART FIGURE 2 Temporal patterns in the proportion of owners reporting cost as the primary reason for surrendering dogs and cats to the Anti-Cruelty Society Animal Shelter (Chicago, Illinois) between January 1 and September 15 of each year from 2000 to 2010. The dashed lines are the predicted values estimated by the data from 2000 to 2007 using Holt s exponential smoothing method. C indicates the observed value is above the 95% upper limit for the predicted value. senior dogs and kittens than in the adult cats. Temporal patterns changed, particularly in dog adoption, after adjusting for the number of animals relinquished. Using the data from 2000 to 2007, the projected trends in the proportion of dogs adopted were increasing across the three age groups, contrasting with a steeply decreasing trend seen in the number of puppies adopted. The proportion in dogs adopted consistently showed decreases after the start of the recession compared with the trend before the recession, regardless of the age of the animals (Figure 3c). Less consistent findings were observed in the proportion of cats adopted (Figure 3d). The projected trend using the data from 2000 to 2007 showed a consistent decline in the numbers of adult dogs and kittens euthanized during the recession period at the ACS shelter (Figure 4a, 4b). The observed number of dogs euthanized was greater than the predicted values, whereas the observed number of adult cats euthanized was lower than the predicted values. After adjusting for the number of animals relinquished, an increase in the proportion of dogs euthanized still appeared (Figure 4c and 4d). DISCUSSION To our knowledge, this is the first study to scientifically investigate the impact of a recession on companion animal (canine and feline) relinquishment, adoption,
IMPACT OF THE ECONOMIC RECESSION 85 (a) (b) FIGURE 3 Temporal patterns in the numbers and proportions of animals adopted among those surrendered to the Anti-Cruelty Society Animal Shelter (Chicago, Illinois) by their owners between January 1 and September 15 of each year from 2000 to 2010. The dashed lines are the predicted values estimated by the data from 2000 to 2007 using Holt s exponential smoothing method. C indicates the observed value is above the 95% upper limit for the predicted value and * indicates the observed value is below the 95% lower limit for the predicted value. Puppy or kitten: less than 6 months old; Adult: from 6 months to less than 8 years old; Senior: 8 years or older. (continued on following page) and euthanasia. However, the study data were collected from only one animal shelter (the ACS shelter) serving mainly the metropolitan area of Chicago, Illinois, a region that includes other shelters. Therefore, the results from this study might only be representative of the participating animal shelter. Nonetheless, this study presented a simple method to investigate how the current recession affects
86 WENG AND HART FIGURE 3 (c) (d) (Continued) those commonly collected shelter statistics. One necessary assumption applied, while making such inferences by comparing the temporal patterns before and after the start of the recession, is that the current recession was the only factor that differed between these two time periods. Our findings suggest that once the ownership of a nonhuman animal has been established, the recent economic recession does not affect cat owners decisions on relinquishing the animal. The data showed that the number of cats relinquished after the start of the recession did not differ from the prerecession period, excepting a decrease in kittens and adult cats relinquished in 2010. Opposite to the temporal patterns observed in the number of cats relinquished, the number of senior dogs relinquished during the recession was greater than the projected trend using the prerecession data.
IMPACT OF THE ECONOMIC RECESSION 87 (a) (b) FIGURE 4 Temporal patterns in the numbers and proportions of animals euthanized among those surrendered to the Anti-Cruelty Society Animal Shelter (Chicago, Illinois) by their owners between January 1 and September 15 of each year from 2000 to 2010. The dashed lines are the predicted values estimated by the data from 2000 to 2007 using Holt s exponential smoothing method. C indicates the observed value is above the 95% upper limit for the predicted value and * indicates the observed valued is below the 95% lower limit for the predicted value. Puppy or kitten: less than 6 months old; Adult: from 6 months to less than 8 years old; Senior: 8 years or older. (continued on following page) To further study how the recession has affected relinquishment, we investigated the primary reasons for relinquishment, which were believed to be associated with the owner s financial status. Cost was the only factor among the three investigated primary reasons for relinquishment that showed a significant increase from the projected trend using the prerecession data. In addition, the
88 WENG AND HART FIGURE 4 (c) (d) (Continued) increase in reporting cost as the primary reason for relinquishment was observed more consistently among dog owners than in cat owners. The shelter records also suggest that an unfavorable economic environment may discourage people from adopting animals. We investigated both the number and proportion of animals adopted in this study. Although the number of animals adopted might reflect more closely the demands of the community, this measure depends heavily on the number of animals relinquished. Combining the findings of the trends in the numbers of animals relinquished and adopted would explain the differences between the findings using absolute numbers and proportions of animals adopted. Greater differences were observed in dog adoptions than in cat adoptions as the number of dogs relinquished to the ACS shelter varied more across the years than did the number of cats relinquished. Despite these differ-
IMPACT OF THE ECONOMIC RECESSION 89 ences, both measures numbers and proportions of animal adopted suggested a decrease in animal adoptions during the recession period compared with the prerecession period. The findings also showed that a more consistent decrease in the proportion of animals adopted was observed in dogs than in cats. The consequences of a decline in animal adoptions might be reflected in an increase in the number and proportion of sheltered animals euthanized in recent years. However, inconsistent findings of the trends in euthanasia indicate that other factors may also contribute to the shelter s decisions on euthanasia (Rogelberg et al., 2007). The findings that only a very small proportion of senior animals at the shelter have been adopted deserve further discussion. The shelter records revealed that illness of animals could not explain the high proportion of animals euthanized in this age group because the percentage reporting illness of animals as the primary reason for relinquishment ranged from only 4% (in 2010) to 61% (in 2003). In addition, the proportion of those reporting illness of animals as the primary reason for relinquishment did not differ before and after the start of the recession. These findings together suggest that incentive programs, such as low cost spay/neuter and veterinary care, commonly offered by animal shelters during this difficult time may show greater benefits and effectiveness in promoting animal adoptions (Frank & Carlisle-Frank, 2007; White, Jefferson, & Levy, 2010). Although a longer follow-up is needed to confirm whether the observed direction of temporal trends continues, the findings of a greater and more consistent impact of the current economic recession on dog adoption are not surprising, considering that the cost for having a dog is greater than the cost of having a cat. The results from the investigation of reporting cost as the primary reason for relinquishment further support this argument. CONCLUSION In summary, the results from this study suggest that the current recession has a greater impact on animal adoption than on relinquishment and consistently affects dogs more than cats. Therefore, promoting adoption may be one of the most important strategies to avoid an increase in euthanizing unwanted animals. However, whether promoting adoptions will alter the number of future relinquishments was not evaluated in this study. Providing assistance to new adopters should be equally important for promoting adoptions to ensure the success of ownership. Because the data were collected from only one animal shelter in a limited geographic area and included only 3 years after the start of the recession, conducting continued monitoring of the trends and getting a representative sample of animal shelters in the United States are crucial. Nonetheless, this study demonstrated how monitoring changes in temporal patterns in these
90 WENG AND HART shelter statistics can help guide animal shelters to better prepare for the current recession. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the Morris Animal Foundation (Grant D09MS-803). This project would not have been possible without the help of the Anti-Cruelty Society in Chicago, Illinois. Special thanks to Dr. Robyn Barbiers (President of the Anti-Cruelty Society), Tamra Wagenknecht (Director of Shelter Services), and the staff members who helped with the survey. Finally, we thank Dr. Locksley Messam for his insightful comments. REFERENCES DiGiacomo, N., Arluke, A., & Patronek, G. (1998). Surrendering pets to shelters: The relinquisher s perspective. Anthrozoös, 11, 41 51. Frank, J. M., & Carlisle-Frank, P. L. (2007). Analysis of programs to reduce overpopulation of companion animals: Do adoption and low-cost spay/neuter programs merely cause substitution of sources? Ecological Economics, 62, 740 746. Marston, L. C., & Bennett, P. C. (2003). Reforging the bond-towards successful canine adoption. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 83, 227 245. National Bureau of Economic Research. (2010). U.S. business cycle expansions and contractions. Retrieved from http://www.nber.org/cycles/cyclesmain.html New, J. C., Salman, M. D., King, M., Scarlett, J. M., Kass, P. H., & Hutchinson, J. (2000). Characteristics of shelter-relinquished animals and their owners compared with animals and their owners in U.S. pet-owning households. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 3, 179 201. Olson, P. N., & Moulton, C. (1993). Pet (dog and cat) overpopulation in the United States. Journal of Reproduction and Fertility Supplement, 47, 433 438. Patronek, G. J., Beck, A. M., & Glickman, L. T. (1997). Dynamics of dog and cat populations in a community. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 210, 637 642. Patronek, G. J., Glickman, L. T., Beck, A. M., & McCabe, G. P. (1996). Risk factors for relinquishment of dogs to an animal shelter. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 209, 572 581. Patronek, G. J., Glickman, L. T., Beck, A. M., McCabe, G. P., & Ecker, C. (1996). Risk factors for relinquishment of cats to an animal shelter. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 209, 582 588. Posage, J. M., Bartlett, P. C., & Thomas, D. K. (1998). Determining factors for successful adoption of dogs from an animal shelter. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 213, 478 482. Rogelberg, S. G., Reeve, C. L., Spitzmuller, C., DiGiacomo, N., Clark, O. L., Teeter, L., & Carter, N. T. (2007). Impact of euthanasia rates, euthanasia practices, and human resource practices on employee turnover in animal shelters. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 230, 713 719. Scarlett, J. M. (2008). Interface of epidemiology, pet population issues and policy. Preventive Veterinary Medicine, 86(34), 188 197. White, S. C., Jefferson, E., & Levy, J. K. (2010). Impact of publicly sponsored neutering programs on animal population dynamics at animal shelters: The New Hampshire and Austin experiences. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 13, 191 212.