NOTE BRÈVE THE TIMING OF BREEDING AND CLUTCH SIZE OF BLUE TITS (PARUS CAER ULEUS) IN AN EVERGREEN HOLM OAK HABITAT IN SOUTHERN SPAIN Paul ISENMANN *, Enrique ALES ** & Oscar MORENO ** Each species is subject to sorne environmental heterogeneity within its breeding range. Consequently, sorne of its life-history traits such as its breeding season and its clutch-size vary, allowing the species to better adapt to the different parts of its breeding range. In the Blue Tit (Parus caeruleus), which breeds from the Canary Islands to northem Europe, and from the British Isles to the Ural Mountains, this variability is particularly marked in the Mediterranean area (Snow, 1956 ; Blondel et al., 1987 ; lsenmann, 1987). Its mean clutch size drops from about 11 eggs in the deciduous habitats of southem France to 3.5 eggs in the Canary Islands (Isenmann, 1987). We report here further data collected by two of us (EA and OM) in an evergreen Holm Oak (Quercus ilex) habitat in Andalusia (southem Spain) during three breeding seasons. This Blue Tit population belonging to the caeruleus group has a small size (Vaurie, 1959 ; Martin, 1988), the earliest known breeding season in Europe and a moderately low clutch size. MATERIAL AND METHODS The study site is a «dehesa», i.e. a rangeland with scattered Holm Oaks (Quercus ilex), at 500 rn elevation near El Pedroso (37.50'N, 05.45W), 60 km north of Sevilla (see Joffre & Rambal, 1988 and Joffre et al., 1988 for details on the dehesas and Merce, 1988 for the climate). We used 30 Schwegler nestboxes in 1985, 1987 and 1988, which were visited once a week during the breeding season (March to May). The Blue Tit is one of the most abundant breeding species in such forests ; for details on the bird communities in this kind of habitat, see Herrera (1980). Clutch size RESULTS The values (Table 1) ranged between 6 and 11 eggs (4 x 6, 15 x 7, 20 x 8, 7 x 9, 4 x 10 and 1 x 11 eggs). Clutches of 7 and 8 eggs were the most common (69 %) and the mean value for 51 clutches was of 7.9 ± 1.1 eggs. (*) Centre d'ecologie Fonctionnelle et Evolutive (CNRS), B.P. 5051, F-34033 Montpellier. (**) Grupo Ornitologico del Sur, Apartado 1067, E-41080 Sevilla. Rev. Eco/. (Terre Vie), vol. 45, 1990-177 -
Breeding time The mean values of the laying date of the first egg varied between March 16 and 28 in three different years (Table I). The earliest recorded laying date was March 8 (1988). TABLE I Breeding parameters of the Blue Tit population breeding at El Pedroso ( Andalusia, Southern Spain). The breeding success is given by the number of young ftedged as % of eggs laid. SD : Standard deviation. N Clutch size (SD) (Range) Laying date (SD) (Range) Y ound ftedged of eggs laid 1985 19 1987 18 1988 14 7.5 (0.8) March 28 (6.6) (6-9) (March 18-April 11) 8.5 (1.2) March 18 (4.4) (7-11) (March 12-March 29) 7.6 (1.2) March 16 (7.6) (6-10) (March 8-April 2) 68 % (143) 80 % (153) 65 % (107) Breeding success The breeding success (Table I) remained within the range known for hole-nesting birds in nestboxes ; it was very high in 1987, the year with the highest mean clutch size. DISCUSSION The average clutch size of this Blue Tit population is much lower than that of populations living in deciduous oak forests elsewhere in Europe. The difference is of 2.4 to 4. 1 eggs (Isenmann, 1987). If compared with values from the same ki nd of habitats, i.e., evergreen oak forests in Mediterranean lowland areas (Table II), the El Pedroso clutches are well within the known limits. Unfortunately we failed to find published data from other areas in Mediterranean Spain (see Potti et al., 1988 for data from a highland deciduous forest site). Finally, the El Pedroso clutches do not differ from those from southern France, but they are significantly larger (T-test, p < 0.01) than those from Corsica, Mallorca and Morocco. Corsican (and probably Mallorcan) blue tits exhibit special features related to insularity (Blondel & Isenmann, 1979 ; Isenmann, 1982 ; Blondel, 1985). The smaller clutches are those of the Corsican blue tits, with a mean clutch size of 6.2 eggs, and the larger ones those of a southern french site, Quissac (Gard), with 8.1 eggs. Furthermore, unpublished data from a second Holm Oak study site in southern France (Les Maures, Var) show that the mean clutch size varied between 178 -
TABLE Il Mean c/utch sizes of Blue Tit populations breeding in lowland evergreen Mediterranean habitats. S.D. : Standard deviation, N : Sample size. Mean Range S.D. N Quissac (France) Corsica (France) Majorca (Spain) Andalucia (Spain) 8.1 6.2 6.9 7.9 6-12 4-8 4-8 6-10 1.5 1.0 1.2 1.1!51 21 51 Isenmann, 1987 Isenmann, 1987 J. Muntaner, in litt. This study Mamora (Morocco) 6.8 5-9 1.1 42 Isenmann, 1987 97 7.3 and 8.5 eggs in five years (Ph. Orsini, unpublished). These values fit weil with those obtained near Montpellier and at El Pedroso. Further data from other Blue Tit populations breeding in continental evergreen oak habitats are needed to confirm that the limits do not differ from those recorded in the three previously mentioned populations. The overall food availability prevailing in a given habitat is likely to be largely responsible for the breeding performances of its nesting birds. It is generally assumed that the food supply of blue tits in Mediterranean habitats does not vary much with the season, so that the spring food surplus is not as great as that taking place in a deciduous habitat of Central or Northern Europe. If the breeding effort of the bird is adjusted to this surplus (see Ricklefs, 1980 ; Koenig, 1984), it is not surprising that birds nesting in Mediterranean habitats lay smaller clutches, and therefore feed smaller numbers of nestlings than those breeding further north. Sorne other important factors may also play a determinant role in clutch size variation, such as the duration of the photoperiod which is shorter at lower latitudes, enabling parents to feed fewer nestlings (Lack, 1968). The El Pedroso birds feed their nestlings at a time where daylight lasts about 12 hours. Populations breeding further north and later in the year benefit from a longer day. However, when one considers only the birds breeding in the Mediterranean evergreen oak belt, the «northern» ones do not lay more eggs than the «southern» ones. The breeding period of the Andalusian Blue Tit population studied is remarkably early. This is indeed the one with the earliest known breeding season in Europe and in North Africa, except for the Canary Islands. If we assume that the breeding period lasts about 40 days (8 days for egg laying, 14 days for incubation and 18 days for the nestling period), the breeding period ended as early as April 24 in 1988, and as late as May 6 in 1985, on the average. As no second clutches were noticed, the breeding season was virtually completed during the last decade of April for most of the earl y breeding pairs, and in the first decade of May for most of the la te breeders. The mild March temperatures, the sharp changes in temperature and precipitation (see Herrera, 1980), and apparently an adequate food supply allow the birds to start breeding early, and favour its termination when the hot summer temperatures and drought conditions begin in May. In 179 -
Corsica the breeding period is curiously delayed until May and June (Blondel, 1985). Preliminary data also indicate that another island population (Majorca, Spain) bas a similar late breeding period (J. Muntaner, unpublished). In Corsica, such a delay apparently results from a trade-off between trophic constraints that postpone the onset of breeding on the one band, and elima tic constraints that set the limits beyond which breeding becomes impossible on the other (Blondel, 1987 ; Perret et al., 1989). This is apparently why the onset of breeding differs between Andalusian and Corsican populations by as much as two months : indeed, Corsican blue tits start breeding when their Andalusian counterparts stop doing so. These two populations differ the most in the timing of their breeding in Mediterranean evergreen habitats. RÉSUMÉ Les Mésanges bleues se reproduisant dans une forêt de Chênes verts d'andalousie dans le sud de l'espagne ont la période de reproduction la plus précoce notée en Europe et même en Afrique du Nord (les dates moyennes de ponte du premier œuf ont oscillé entre le 16 et le 28 mars pendant 3 ans). La taille de ponte moyenne {7,9 œufs), par contre, se place dans les limites de variation observées pour ce paramètre dans d'autres formations sempervirentes méditerranéennes. Les populations de Corse (où les Mésanges bleues se reproduisent en moyenne 2 mois plus tard) et d'andalousie montrent les extraordinaires limites de variation de la période de reproduction de cette espèce en zone méditerranéenne. Les raisons de cette variation sont à rechercher dans les particularités d'ordre climatique et trophique de chacun de ces habitats ; leur relative pauvreté ne permettant que des tailles de ponte relativement faibles. SUMMARY Blue tits breeding in an evergreen Holm Oak forest in Southern Spain have the earliest breeding period recorded for the species in Europe and northern Africa. Their clutch sizes fall within the ranges known for the Mediterranean Evergreen Oak belt. The populations of Corsica, where breeding starts two months la ter, and those of Andalusia, illustra te the wide seasonal variations of the breeding season of this species in the Mediterranean zone. Such a variation is probably due to differences in food availability and climatic constraints between different areas. Lower values of food availability obviously do not allow the production of large clutch sizes. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Our thanks go to P. Alpert, J. Blondel, F. Bourlière and P. Duncan who commented a first draft and to J. Muntaner and Ph. Orsini who provided us with their unpublished data. REFERENCES BLONDEL, J. (1985). - Comparative breeding ecology of the Blue Tit and the Coal Tit in mainland and island Mediterranean habitats. Journal of Animal Eco/ogy, 54 : 531-556. 180 -
BLONDEL, J. (1987). - Vers une approche intégrée de la biologie des populations de mésanges. Actes du Colloque National CNRS «Biologie des Populations», 25-33. BLONDEL, J., CLAMENS, A., CRAMM, P., GAUBERT, H. & ISENMANN, P. (1987). - Population studies on tits in the Mediterranean region. Ardea, 75 : 21-34. BLONDEL, J. & ISENMANN, P. (1979). - Insularité et démographie des Mésanges du genres Parus (Aves). Comptes Rendus des Séances de l'académie des Sciences, Paris, 289 : 161-164. HERRERA, C.M. (1980). - Composici6n y estructura de dos communidades mediterraneas de passeriformes. Dofiana, Acta Vertebrata, 7: 1-340. ISENMANN, P. (1982). - The influence of insularity on fecundity in tits (Aves, Paridae) in Corsica. Acta Oeco/ogica, Oecologia Generalis, 3 : 295-301. ISENMANN, P. (1987). - Geographical variation in clutch-size : the example of the Blue Tit (Parus caeruleus) in the Mediterranean area. Voge/warte, 34 : 93-99. JOFFRE, R. & RAMBAL, S. ( 1988). - Soi! water improvement by trees in the range lands of southern Spain. Acta Oeco/ogica, Oeco/ogia Plantarum, 9: 405-422. JOFFRE, R., VACHER, J., DE LOS LLANOS, C. & LONG, G. (1988). - The dehasa : an agrosilvopastoral system of the Mediterranean region with special reference to the Sierra Morena area of Spain. Agroforestry Systems, 6: 71-96. KOENIG, W. (1984). - Geographie variation in clutch size in the Northern Flicker (Co/aptes auratus) : support for Ashmole's hypothesis. Auk, 101 : 698-706. LACK, D. (1968). - Ecologica/ Adaptations for Breeding in Birds. Methuen, London. MARTIN, J.L. (1988). - Structure de population et variations «périspécifiques» chez Parus caeruleus (Aves) : premiers résultats. Acta Oecologica, Oecologia Generalis, 9: 153-166. MERCE, J. (1988). - Bioclimats du sud de l'espagne. Eco/ogia Mediterranea,!4 : 65-76. PERRET, P., BLONDEL, J., DERVIEUX, A., MAISTRE, M. & COLOMB, B. (1989). - Composante génétique de la date de ponte chez la Mésange bleue (Parus caeruleus). Comptes Rendus des Séances de l'académie des Sciences, Paris, 308/111 : 527-530. POTT!, J., MONTALVO, S., SANCHEZ-AGUADO, F.J. & BLANCO, D. (1988). - La reproduccion del Herrerillo comun (Parus caeru/eus) en un robledal del centro de Espaîia. Ardeo/a, 35 : 31-43. RICKLEFS, R.E. (1980). - Geographical variation in clutch size among passerine birds : Ashmole's hypothesis. Auk, 97 : 38-49. SNOW, D. (1956). - The annual mortality of the Blue Tit in different parts of its range. British Birds, 49 : 174-177. VAURIE, C. (1959). - The Birds of the Palaearctic Fauna. Witherby, London. 181