Paleoecological Analysis of the Early Pleistocene Vertebrate Fauna from Razvodje and Tatinja draga (Croatia)

Similar documents
VARIABILITY OF AMPHIBIANS AND REPTILES OF RUSSIAN PLAIN: EVOLUTIONARY, ECOLOGICAL AND PRESERVATION ASPECTS

ECOLOGICAL ASPECTS ON LIZARD POPULATIONS FROM OBCINELE BUCOVINEI (SUCEAVA)

British Reptiles. By Sue Searle

VERTEBRATA PALASIATICA

Acorn Ecology Certificate Course Self-Study Tutorial. British Reptile & Amphibian ID ( and a bit about surveying too!)

NOTES ON THE ALTITUDINAL DISTRIBUTION OF LIZARDS AND SOME OTHER REPTILES ON MOUNT BIOKOVO (CROATIA) AND ITS IMMEDIATE SURROUNDINGS

International Society for the History and Bibliography. of Herpetology

First record of a melanistic Italian Wall Lizard (Podarcis sicula) in Slovenia

VIRIDOR WASTE MANAGEMENT LIMITED. Parkwood Springs Landfill, Sheffield. Reptile Survey Report

NATURA MONTENEGRINA, Podgorica, 2013, 12(1):

An assesstnent of the itnportance of heathlands as habitats for reptiles

A R T I C L E S STRATIGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION OF VERTEBRATE FOSSIL FOOTPRINTS COMPARED WITH BODY FOSSILS

ECOLOGY AND CONSERVATION OF REPTILES IN THE NEW FOREST

Notes on biology and ecology of the Horvath's rock lizard (Lacerta horvathi Mehely, 1904, Reptilia: Lacertidae)

Reptile Identification Guide

Herpetofauna in the city of Blagoevgrad, south-western Bulgaria

Designation of Emerald sites for the conservation of Amphibian and Reptiles: practices and methodology

Appendix 6.4. Reptile Survey

Contribution to the Knowledge on Amphibians and Reptiles of North-western Croatia

Composition of a small mammal community studied by three comparative methods

Erycine Boids from the Early Oligocene of the South Dakota Badlands

HERPETOFAUNA OF STARA ZAGORA, SOUTHERN BULGARIA: SPECIES COMPOSITION AND DISTRIBUTION ALONG THE NATURAL HABITAT URBAN AREAS GRADIENT

14. Species: Vipera ursinii (Bonaparte, 1835)

QuickTime and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture.

Snake envenomation (ophitoxemia) of domestic animals in Croatia - risk factors Maja Lang Balija 1,Marija Brgles 1, Beata Halassy 1

The Small Indian Mongoose Herpestes auropuncatus (Hodgson 1836)in the Balkans

Reptile Method Statement

Animal Biodiversity. Teacher Resources - High School (Cycle 1) Biology Redpath Museum

Reptile Survey of Hampstead Heath

Lot of nice wetlands in corridors with for Europe diverse biodiversity.

ECOLOGICAL NICHE SEGREGATION OF SEVEN SYMPATRIC LACERTID LIZARDS IN THE PELOPONNESE HIGHLANDS

BARRY KEMP CONSERVATION LIMITED ʻAmblehurstʼ Nevill Road Crowborough East Sussex TN6 2RA

Anurans and squamates from the Lower Pliocene (MN 14) Osztramos 1 locality (Northern Hungary)

The Herpetofauna and Ichthyofauna of the Cucumber Creek Watershed in the Ouachita Mountains, LeFlore County, Oklahoma

Global comparisons of beta diversity among mammals, birds, reptiles, and amphibians across spatial scales and taxonomic ranks

GEOL 104 Dinosaurs: A Natural History Homework 6: The Cretaceous-Tertiary Extinction. DUE: Fri. Dec. 8

Section 9.4. Animal bones from excavations at George St., Haymarket, Sydney

New records and zoogeographic classification of amphibians and reptiles from Bosnia and Herzegovina

Introduction to the Cheetah

31/05/2011. Epidemiology and Control Programs for Echinococcus multilocularis. - geography? - frequency? - risk factors? - geography? - frequency?

Writing: Lesson 23. Today the students will practice planning for informative/explanatory prompts in response to text they read.

Acknowledgements. Supported by BMFT-Bundesministerium für Forschung und Technik (FIFB - FKZ A).

Endangered Plants and Animals of Oregon

TAP AG Project Title / Facility Name: Trans Adriatic Pipeline Project. Document Title: Ecological Management Plan CAL00-PMT-601-Y-TTM-0007 Appendix 4

Cumbria Biodiversity Data Centre Cumbria Mammal Group

This article appeared in a journal published by Elsevier. The attached copy is furnished to the author for internal non-commercial research and

Sample Questions: EXAMINATION I Form A Mammalogy -EEOB 625. Name Composite of previous Examinations

Where a vole-carrier dropped after 4 km of soaring and gliding, Racoviţa, July 10 th 2006

Squamates of Connecticut

Postilla PEABODY MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY YALE UNIVERSITY NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT, U.S.A.

FAUNAL DATA, SAN PEDRO PRESERVATION PROJECT

A Population Analysis of the Common Wall Lizard Podarcis muralis in Southwestern France

Integrated ESIA Greece Annex West - Herpetofauna Baseline Study

ESIA Albania Annex 11.4 Sensitivity Criteria

Key concepts of Article 7(4): Version 2008

A contribution to the knowledge of the trophic spectrum of three lacertid lizards from Bulgaria

Introduction to the Cheetah

Appendix 8.5 Reptile Survey Report

Morphology of articular surfaces can solve a phylogenetic issue: one instead of two ancestors for Candiacervus (Mammalia: Cervoidea)

2015 Artikel. article Online veröffentlicht / published online: Deichsel, G., U. Schulte and J. Beninde

DINOSAUR TRACKS AND OTHER FOSSIL FOOTPRINTS OF THE WESTERN UNITED STATES. Martin Lockley and Adrian P. Hunt. artwork by Paul Koroshetz

Yr 11 Evolution of Australian Biota Workshop Students Notes. Welcome to the Australian Biota Workshop!! Some of the main points to have in mind are:

8/19/2013. What is a community? Topic 21: Communities. What is a community? What are some examples of a herp species assemblage? What is a community?

PRELIMINARY REPORT ON A CLUTCH OF SIX DINOSAURIAN EGGS FROM THE UPPER TRIASSIC ELLIO T FORMATION, NORTHERN ORANGE FREE STATE. J. W.

2015 Artikel. article Online veröffentlicht / published online: Ron Peek

Assessing the needs for a sound management of the introduced populations of reptiles and amphibians in Italy

Appendix 8.18 Reptile Survey Report 2014

Towarzystwo Herpetologiczne NATRIX Wrocław REASERCHERS: PROJECT COORDINATOR. Edyta Turniak tel.

Observations on a population of adders, slow-worms and common lizards on Loch Lomondside, Scotland

Hyla VOL , No. 2, Str.3-17 ISSN:

Tuesday, December 6, 11. Mesozoic Life

The Middle Pleistocene Herpetofaunas from Kärlich (Neuwied Basin, Germany) J. Alan Holman and Thijs van Kolfschoten

Derwent Forest Reptile Survey Report. November 2009

LAND AT REAR OF PARAPET HOUSE LENHAM KENT REPTILE SCOPING SURVEY

COUNTRY LEGISLATION GIVING PROTECTION SCHEDULE OR

NARWHALS. The decrease of the Monodon monoceros population. By Caitlin Seppi

Field Guide: Teacher Notes

1 Sorting It All Out. Say It

NARRS REPORT

Preliminary results on the stratigraphy and taphonomy of multiple bonebeds in the Triassic of Algarve

Impact of colour polymorphism in free ranging asp vipers

Raptor Ecology in the Thunder Basin of Northeast Wyoming

NATIONAL HERTETOLOGY List posted o n under Event Based upon information at

SUPPLEMENTARY ONLINE MATERIAL FOR

35. DATA REPORT: CRETACEOUS OSTRACODES FROM HOLES 865A AND 866A (MID-PACIFIC MOUNTAINS) 1. Renée Damotte 2

GROWTH AND PLUMAGE DEVELOPMENT OF KESTREL (FALCO TINNUNCULUS LINNAEUS, 1758) NESTLINGS IN A NEST IN VOIVODINA (YUGOSLAVIA) Jene J.

Evolution of Birds. Summary:

Talks generally last minutes and take place in one of our classrooms.

ANNUAL PREDATION MANAGEMENT PROJECT REPORTING FORM

ALEXANDRU IFTIME, OANA IFTIME

THE SKULLS OF ARAEOSCELIS AND CASEA, PERMIAN REPTILES

AMENDMENTS TO APPENDICES I AND II OF THE CONVENTION. Other Proposals

Title: Phylogenetic Methods and Vertebrate Phylogeny

THE FOOD OF THE RED FOX (VULPES VULPES L) AND THE MARTEN (MARTES FOINA, ERXL) IN THE SPRING-SUMMER PERIOD IN OSOGOVO MOUNTAIN

Variation in body temperatures of the Common Chameleon Chamaeleo chamaeleon (Linnaeus, 1758) and the African Chameleon Chamaeleo africanus

ARTEDUCATION. Ing. Jiří H A L E Š 1

Three snakes from coastal habitats at Pulau Sugi, Riau Islands, Indonesia

LLWR Ecology Framework


Ciccaba virgata (Mottled Owl)

Transcription:

Beitr. Paläont. 25:87-94, Wien 2000 Paleoecological Analysis of the Early Pleistocene Vertebrate Fauna from Razvodje and Tatinja draga (Croatia) by Maja P aunovic 1} and Gernot R abeder *2) Paunovic, M. & R abeder, G., 2000. Paleoecological Analysis of the Early Pleistocene Vertebrate Fauna from Razvodje and Tatinja draga (Croatia). Beitr. Palaont., 25:87-94, 6 figs., 7 tables, Wien. Abstract In this paper are presented the results of paleoecological analysis of the vertebrate assemblages from bone-breccias found in Croatia along the Adriatic coast near Razvodje (Lower Early Pleistocene) and Tatinja draga (Middle Early Pleistocene). Because of the differences in the community structure and frequencies of registered taxa they are designed as Lagurus-Podarcis sicula assemblage (Tatinja draga) and Allophaiomys-Microtus-Lacerta agilis assemblage (Razvodje). Analysis also shows that at both localities the arid biocoenoses are accompanied with mesophyllous areas, bushes and open landscape biotopes developed under temperateound periodically humid climatic conditions, as well as similarity with contemporary faunas of Italy, Austria and southeastern Europe. Endemic small vertebrate taxa and the presence of species living today in the area indicate that the main features of the recent fauna were formed during the Early Pleistocene. 1. Introduction Best known from the numerous localities of the bonebreccias along the Adriatic coast are Sandalja I near Pula (Istria), Podumci near Unesic (Dalmatia), as well as Tatinja draga near Karlobag and Razvodje near Knin, but until 1980 only faunal lists or paleontological descriptions of the skeletal remains have been published (Kormos 1918,1931, Kowalski 1958, M alez 1971). Therefore the recent studies of the faunal assemblages, especially of the micromammals, include also biostratigraphical analyses: the Early Pleistocene age of the bone-breccias discovered at Tatinja draga, n Dr. Maja Paunovic, Institute of Quartemary Paleontology and Geology, Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts, A. Kovacica 5, Hr-10000 Zagreb, Croatia 2) Dr. Gernot Rabeder, Institute of Palaeontology, University of Vienna, Geozentrum, Althanstr. 14, A -1090 Vienna, Austria Razvodje and Podumci was confirm ed by the morphogenetic analyses of micromammals (Malez & R abeder 1984, P aunovic & R abeder 1996), with reference to geochronologically important arvicolids. Metrical data and molar morphotypes of the genus Lagurus, as well as Pliomys indicate that the fauna from Razvodje (Lower Early Pleistocene) is older than the fauna from Tatinja draga (M iddle Early Pleistocene), and Podumci (Late Early Pleistocene). At the same time, analyses of the lower vertebrates shows differences between Razvodje and Tatinja draga (P aunovic & R abeder 1996). Therefore using the results of paleontological and statistical analyses of all faunal remains, we have tried to reconstruct the ecological relationships in these two chronologically and geographically separated assemblages. 2. Localities The studied Early Pleistocene bone-breccias were found in karstic fissures of Paleogene rocks at Tatinja draga near Karlobag on the foot of the Mt. Velebit and Razvodje near Knin on the slopes of Mt. Promina (Fig. 1). The bone-breccia matrix from Tatinja draga is reddish-brown in colour, reflecting a temperate climate during the deposition, while the yellowish-green sandy clay matrix from Razvodje was deposited under colder clim atic conditions (M alez & R abeder 1984, Paunovic & R abeder 1996). A small amount of large mammal remains in distinction from the small mammals and lower vertebrates is characteristic for both of the studied localities. 3. Large Mammals After the first publication of some faunal remains from Tatinja draga (K ormos 1918), M. M alez (1960,1968, 1971) also listed the large mammals in his papers (Table 1). The preliminary list of the macromammal remains from the bone-breccia at Razvodje was published in 1971 by M. M alez (Table 1).

88 Beitr. Paláont., 25, Wien 2000 According to the data from the literature (Table 1) the faunal assemblages are similar: in Tatinja draga Capreolus suessenbornensis is missing, while in Razvodje Vulpes has not been registered. Regretably, in both cases the number of remains and frequency of taxa is not listed. For the moment, the determination made by M alez (1971) must be accepted and the only conclusion is, that the listed large mammals are both forest- and open forest-dwelling taxa (except forequus stenonis), which appear to have been sympatric in the Early Pleistocene faunas from Croatia. Thus, after the large mammals, the age of the faunas from Razvodje and Tatinja draga is Early Biharian (Villany-5), or due to the sedimentation processes (if determination of the large mammals is correct) the studied faunal assemblages are composed of the mixed remains belonging to the various stages of Early Pleistocene. Namely, Equus stenonis and Ursus arvernensis are no longer present in Tamanian (Betfian) assemblages of SE Species Razvodje Tatinja draga Canis sp. Vulpes sp. Ursus arvernensis Mustela sp. x x Equus stenonis x Cervus sp. Capreolus sp. Capreolus cf. suessenbornensis x Table 1. Large mammals from Razvodje and Tatinja draga (after M alez, 1971). Species Razvodje Tatinja draga Talpa minor Talpa europaea Sorex runtonensis Episoriculus thenii Beremendia fissidens Crocidura kornfeldi Hypolagus brachygnathus Lepus sp. Marmota sp. Sciurus sp. Glis sackdillingensis Allocricetus croaticus Allocricetus bursae Microtus praehintoni Microtus ratticeps Mimomys malezi Mimomys savini Mimomys pusillus Dinaromys dalmatinus Pliomys cf. schernfeldensis Pliomys simplicior Pliomys bolkayi Pliomys cf. hollitzeri Lagurus arankae Apodemus cf. sylvaticus Apodemus mystacinus epimelas Table 2. Small mammals from Razvodjie and Tatinja draga. Europe (Rekovets & Krakhmalnaya 1998). Also, after A lberdi, Caloi & Palombo (1998) the comparative analysis of large mammals from Italy (Farneta and Pirro faunal unit = Early Pleistocene = Biharian) shows a dominance of open enivronments-dwelling taxa, and U. arvernensis and E. stenonis were not found in these assemblages. In Farneta unit successive and rapid spreads of grazer elements took place interspersed with short phases of partial reforestation. The different types of large mammal assemblages may correspond to the more or less arid or forested phases. In the Pirro faunal unit the species adapted to the open environments reached their maximum, although some elements that inhabit environments with a more dense woodland are still present. This unit is probably corresponding to a climatic cooling of the Menapian stage in northern Europe. Thus, the large mammal assemblages from Razvodje and Tatinja draga correspond probably to the Farneta unit and new evaluation of U. arvernensis, E. stenonis as well as Capreolus suessenbornensis remains must be preformed.

Paunovic, M. & R abeder, G., Paleoecological Analysis of 89 Taxa Lower Early Pleistocene Razvodje Middle Early Pleistocene Tatinja draga Modern fauna Episoriculus thenii thenii Allocricetus croaticus (bursae) Apodemus mystacinus epimelas epimelas epimelas Microtus (cf. praehintoni) eoratticeps (div. sp.) Mimomys malezi malezi Dinaromys dalmatinus bogdanovi Pliomys (simplicior) bolkayi Table 3. Endemie small mammal taxa (non-endemic taxa in paenthesis). 4. Small Mammals The taxonomic study of small mammal remains was published in 1996 (P aunovic & R abeder), and therefore only the results are discussed in the present study. The fauna of Razvodje (Table 2, Fig. 2) contains arvicolids (M icrotus cf. praehintoni, Pliomys simplicior / hollitzeri, Mimomys pusillus) which indicate an Early Pleistocene age. A new species of hamster (Allocricetus croaticus) has to be emphasized (Paunovic & R abeder 1996). The fauna of Tatinja draga (Table 2, Fig. 2) contains more individuals and is also dominated by arvicolids (Lagurus arankae, Pliomys bolkayi, P. hollitzeri, Dinaromys dalmatinus, Mimomys savini, M. pusillus). Among these remains Microtus eoratticeps was determined for the first time (Paunovic & Rabeder 1996). From the registered small m ammals, Sciurus, Allocricetus croaticus, Microtus praehintoni, Pliomys schernfeldensis and Pliomys simplicior are missing in the assemblage from Tatinja draga, while in the assemblage from Razvodje Talpa europaea, Marmota sp., Pliomys bolkyai and P hollitzeri are not determined (Table 2). The faunal assemblage from Tatinja draga is strongly dominated by Lagurus arankae (76%), while in the assemblage from Razvodje Allocricetus and Microtus taxa were registered with the same frequency of 31 % H Allocricetus Mimomys Pliomys Dinaromys a Lagurus Microtus Apodemus others (Paunovic & R abeder 1996). So, considering the frequency of Lagurus, Microtus and Allocricetus, the assemblage from Razvodje can be designed as "Microtus-Allocricetus fauna and the one from Tatinja draga as Lagurus-fauna Species Razvodje Tatinja draga Phoxinus sp. (Ph.) 2 (50%) Cypriniformes (Cyp) 2 (50%) E 4 Bufo viridis (Bv) 2 (6%) Rana latastei (RI) 3 (9%) Rana arvalis (Ra) 1(3%) Rana sp. (R) 5 (15%) Hyla arbórea (Ha) 3 (9%) Bombina bombina (Bb) 1 (3%) Anura indet. (A) 19 (55%) Z 34 Lacerta viridis (Lv) 17 (12%) 7 (4%) Lacerta agilis (La) 17 (12%) 5 (3%) Lacerta oxycephala (Lo) 11 (8%) 3 (2%) Lacerta lepida (LI) 7 (5%) 5 (3%) Lacerta vivípara (Lvi) 2 (1%) Lacerta sp. (L) 57 (41%) 84 (52%) Podareis muralis (Pm) 9 (6%) 9 (5%) Podareis sicula (Ps) 14 (10%) 22 (13%) Podareis sp. (P) 18 (11%) Anguis fragilis (Af) 2 (1%) 1 (0,5%) Ophisaurus pannonicus (O) 2 (1%) 7 (4%) Anguinidae (An) 1 (0,5% ) Z 138 162 Vípera ammodytes (Va) 4 (11%) 1 (8%) Vípera berus (Vb) 2 (6%) Vípera sp. (V) 4 (11%) 1 (8%) Coronelía austriaca (Ca) 6 (17%) 6 (50%) Coronelía sp. (C) 3 (8%) Elaphe longissima (El) 3 (25%) Elaphe sp. (E) 3 (8%) Natrix natrix (Nn) 2 (6%) Natrix sp. (N) 3 (8%) Coluber sp. (CI) 2 (6%) Colubrinae (Col) 1 (3%) 1 (8%) Serpentes indet. (S) 5 (14%) Z 35 12 Figure 2. Frequencies of rodent taxa in % (after P aunovic & Table 4. Number of determined skeletal remains of lower R abeder, 1996). vertebrates from Razvodje and Tatinja draga (figs. -5).

90 Beitr. Paláont., 25, Wien 2000 Among the fauna a high amount of endemic taxa is remarkable: Episoriculus thenii, Allocricetus croaticus, Apodemus mystacinus epimelas, Microtus eoratticeps, Mimomys malezi, Dinaromys dalmatinus, Pliomys bolkayi (Table 3). 5. Lower Vertebrates 5.1. Material and Methods The preliminary list of lower vertebrate taxa was published in 1996 (Paunovic & Rabeder). Due to the high amount of well preserved and characteristic skeletal remains, the taxonomy of 214 bones from Tatinja draga, and 174 from Razvodje has been determined after the determination keys (Bohme 1977, Paunovic 1984, R auscher 1992, Szyndlar 1981) as well as in comparison with the skeletal collection of the recent taxa (Table 4). The determination shows that in the assemblage from Razvodje the fish and frogs are not represented, while in the assemblage from Tatinja draga snakes are registered in small number (Table 5, Fig. 3). In the same time, both assemblages are dominated by lacertids, but with high percentage of only generically determined skeletal remains due to the number of strongly damaged bones and / or teeth (Table 4). Therefore, due to the results of the taxonomy, for comparison and evaluation of these two assemblages, the statistical analysis of frogs, lizards and snakes remains was made separately. 5.2. Statistical Analysis of Skeletal Remains 5.2.1. Pisces The four bones found among the material from Tatinja draga obviously belong to the cyprinids, respectively to the genus Phoxinus. 5.2.2. Anura From the 34 humeri or ilia 19 (or 55%) obviously belong to frogs, but they are damaged and therefore non-diagnostic. Determined taxa (Table 3) in amount of 45% belong mostly to ranids (27%), then to Hyla arborea (9%), Bufo viridis (6%), and Bombina bombina (3%) (Table 4, Fig 4). 5.2.3. Lacertilia Among lizards from both localities the lacertids dominate in Razvodje with 96% and in Tatinja draga with 91%, while anguinids are registered with only 4% and 9% respectively. Differences between them are the appearance of Lacerta vivipara in the faunal assemblage from Razvodje, as well as different frequency of taxa (Table 3, Fig. 5). 5.2.4. Serpentes Snakes are more common in the fauna from Razvodje than in Tatinja draga, and among determined taxa the species of Natricinae and Colubrinae are more frequent than those of Viperinae (Table 3, Fig 6). The most frequent species in both faunas is Coronella austriaca (6%). The difference between them is also a number Pisces Anura E Lacertilia 9 Bv Rl Ra i R nha ubb oa Serpentes k S c V f i, l ILLI Tatinja draga -- Figure 3. Frequencies of lower vertebrates from Razvodje Figure 4. Frequencies of frog taxa from Tatinja draga and Tatinja draga. (abbreviations in Table 4) 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% dlb. Razvodje Tatinja draga Figure 5. Frequencies of laceitid taxa from Razvodje and Tatinja draga (abbreviations in Table 4). Fn I! f i i S i :J Q _ 1TTTH1 Z 3 um& i ; _ i Razvodje Tatinja draga m Va Vb n v C ca E E N S Ca S E I Nn tcci Col S Figure 6. Frequencies of snake taxa from Razvodje and Tatinja draga (abbreviations in Table 4).

Paunovic, M. & R abeder, G., Paleoecological Analysis of 91 of determined taxa: among snakes from Tatinja draga only 4 species were determined, while the list of Razvodje consists of 7 (Table 3, Fig. 6). 5. 3. Community Structure In the present study the changes in the community structure were analysed on the basis of frogs, lacertids and snakes of which the taxonomical position and the number of individual was estimated. Razvodje Tatinja draga Pisces 4 (2%) Anura 34 (16%) Lacertilia 138 (77%) 162 (76%) Serpentes 35 (23%) 12 (6%) I 173 212 Table 5. Frequencies of lower vertebrates from Razvodje and Tatinja draga. Species Razvodje Tatinja draga MNI (P) MNI (P) Bufo viridis 9 (0,18) Rana latastei 2 (0,04) Rana arvalis 1 (0,02) Hyla arbórea 1 (0,02) Bombina bombina 1 (0,02) Lacerta viridis 6 (0,10) 3 (0,06) Lacerta agilis 9 (0,16) 4 (0,08) Lacerta oxycephala 6 (0,10) 2 (0,04) Lacerta lepida 6 (0,10) 2 (0,04) Lacerta vivípara 1 (0,01) Podareis muralis 5 (0,09) 3 (0,06) Podareis sicula 5 (0,09) 9 (0,18) Anguis fragilis 2 (0,03) 1 (0,02) Ophisaurus pannonicus 1 (0,01) 3 (0,06) Vípera ammodytes 4 (0,07) 1 (0,02) Vípera berus 2 (0,03) Coronelía austríaca 6 (0,10) 6 (0,12) Elaphe longissima 1 (0,02) Natrix natrix 2 (0,03) MNI 55 49 S (total number of species) 13 16 H(Shannon index) 3,64 3,90 d (species diversity) 4,007 3,89 e (equitability) 2,56 2,77 Table 6. Quantitative analysis of lower vertebrates from Razvodje and Tatinja draga. The data were expressed in terms of community structure indices, and the results achieved by analysis of the relative frequency for each species (P = n / N), as well as of the number of species (species diversity) calculated from the equation: d = S-l / In N (S = number of species, N = number of individuals), while the degree to which individual species are evenly represented (dominance or equitability) was computed from the equation e = H / In S (H = Shannon index calculated from equation after N adachowski 1998). Biotop forest open forest open landscape steppe stony landscape karst running water stagnant water moor Small vertebrates Sorex, Talpa, Lepus, Sciurus, Glis, Apodemus, Rana latastei, Hyla arbórea, Lacerta agilis, Vípera berus, Elaphe longissima, Coronelía austríaca Crocidura, Lepus, Hypolagus, Talpa, Hyla arbórea, Anguis fragilis, Lacerta agilis Lagurus, Marmota, Allocricetus, Pliomys Dinaromys, Lacerta viridis, Lacerta lepida, Podareis muralis, Podareis sicula, Ophisaurus pannonicus, Vípera ammodytes, Coronelía austríaca Phoxinus, Natrix natrix Bombina bombina, Lacerta vivípara, Vípera berus, Natrix natrix Table 7. Early Pleistocene Biotopes at Razvodje and Tatinja draga. 6. D iscussion Considering the ecology of the listed small vertebrates, six main biotopes which have probably existed in the surroundings of both localities can be distinguished (Table 7). Bufo viridis and Microtus taxa are ecologi

92 Beitr. Palaont., 25, Wien 2000 cally non-diagnostic and therefore not listed in the table. Among other small vertebrates forest- and openforest, open landscape- and steppe-, stony landscapeand karst-dwelling taxa are represented. Also, some of them are w ater-dw elling. In both faunas thermophilous elements art Lacerta viridis, L. lepida, L.oxycephala, Podarcis sicula, P. muralis, Ophisaurus pannonicus, Elaphe longissima, Vipera ammodytes, Coluber, and Coronella austriaca. Generally, at both localities the arid biocoenoses (steppe, stony landscape, karst) are accompanied with m esophilous areas, bushes and open landscape biotopes developed under temperate and periodically humid climatic conditions. Yet, the differences between Razvodje and Tatinja draga are expressed in composition and frequency of taxa. For example, absence of amphibians in the fauna from Razvodje, presence of thermophilous Lacerta oxyce-phala in Tatinja draga with 2%, and in Razvodje with 8% or Lacerta vivipara found only in the assemblage from Razvodje. The Allocricetus- Microtus-Lacerta agilis assemblage from Razvodje is characterized by a high percentage of the steppeand open landscape-dwelling species, with 73% thermophilous elements among lower vertebrates (Tables 3, 7). Similarly, Lagurus-Podarcis sicula assemblage from Tatinja draga consists of 75% thermophilous elements among lower vertebrates (Table 3, 7) and 75% of steppe elements among small mammals. In the same time, the analysis of relative frequencies of lower vertebrate species (P) shows that in the assemblage of Razvodje among lacertids dominates the non-termophillous Lacerta agilis, probably indicating som ew hat cooler clim ate conditions in this area than today. This can also be confirmed by the presence of Vipera berus and Lacerta vivipara (Table 6), and explained with different geographic positions of the localities. Namely, the bone breccia at Tatinja draga is found at the Adriatic coast at approxim ately 15 msl, and the same one at Razvodje at 300 msl on the slopes of Mt. Promina. For example, today the vertical distribution of reptile species on Mt.Velebit and surrounding areas (M rsic 1978, T vrtkovic & K letecki 1993b) shows that Lacerta viridis is spread from 0-300 msl, Lacerta agilis from 850-1500 msl, Lacerta vivipara from 1100-1500 msl, and Podarcis sicula from 0-80 msl. Therefore, also the neotectonic movements must be considered: the most significant, about 1500m, vertical movements were registered on Mt. Velebit (Prelogovic 1975). So, probably in the Early Pleistocene the altitude difference between the two studied localities was less expressed. At the same time, today s undersea springs along the Adriatic coast were probably surface running waters which were caused also by the changes of the sealevel. Thus, the running waters have been the source of the mosaic-like development of mesophyllous forests, meadows and steppe environments under temperate climatic conditions. At the same time the connections and/or migrations of fauna between Central, SE and SW Europe must have been easier because of lack of the physiographic barriers. Namely, in comparison with other Early Pleistocene localities, the small vertebrate fauna is similar to the assemblage from Deutsch- Altenburg (Rauscher 1992) indicating a temperate climate and connection with Central European faunal assemblages. At the same time, faunal assemblages from Razvodje and Tatinja draga are similar to the faunal units of Italy in which forest species are almost equal in number to the open area taxa (Farneta faunal unit found at Pietrafitta: A lberdi et al. 1998), as well as with SE European Tamanian faunas (Rekovets & Krakhmalnaya 1998). Considering also the fact that in the Early Pleistocene this region was far from the Adriatic (maximum regression was during the Late Biharian: N ilsson, 1983), stronger continental influences and different ecological relationships must have prevailed during the deposition of sediments on both localities. Such different relationships also explain the remains of Lacerta lepida whose characteristics are smaller dimensions than these of the recent specimens from the Iberian penninsula. Perhaps, it is question of a Pliocene relict population, which dissappeared from the eastern Adriatic coast during the transgression in Middle Pleistocene. Also, the presence of Lacerta oxycephala (in Tatinja draga 8%, in Razvodje 2%) speaks in favour of different ecological relationships: today L. oxycephala is an endemic species found among small vertebrates in Mediterranean beech forest at Mt. Biokovo near Cetina river, as well as in Konavle near D ubrovnik in Carpinetum o rientalis-belt (Tvrtkovic & K letecki, 1993a). Thus, considering also small mammal taxa, today s fauna of the Adriatic coast was probably formed during the Early Pleistocene as a result of Pliocene migrations and endemism reflecting the influence of climate alterations caused by global changes as well as by the proximity of the Alps and the Dinarids on one side, and by Adriatic sea on the other. At the same time endemism can also be the result of the isolation of populations caused by sealevel changes as well as by neotectonic movements. 7. C onclusion The study of vertebrate fauna from bone-breccias found at Razvodje and Tatinja draga has lead to the following conclusions: With reference to geochronologically important arvicolids, metrical data and molar morphotypes of the Lagurus and Pliomys taxa indicate that the fauna from Razvodje (Lower Early Pleistocene) is older than the fauna from Tatinja draga (Middle Early Pleistocene).

Paunovic, M. & R abeder, G., Paleoecological Analysis of 93 The large mammals from Razvodje and Tatinja draga are both forest- and open forest- dwelling taxa (except Equus stenonis). The assemblages correspond probably to the Farneta unit of Italy and a new evaluation of the skeletal remains described as Ursus arvernensis, Equus stenonis and Capreolus suessenbomensis must be performed. The small mammal assemblage from Tatinja draga is strongly dominated by Lagurus arankae, while in the assem blage from Razvodje the M icrotus and Allocricetus taxa dominate with the same frequency. Also, among the fauna a high amount of endemic taxa is remarkable. Among the lower vertebrates, relative frequency of the species shows that in the assemblage from Razvodje Lacerta agilis and in Tatinja draga Podarcis sicula are dominant. Fewer endemic taxa were registered. Combining the results of community structure analyses the studied faunas can be described as: Microtus-Allocricetus-Lacerta agilis assemblage (Razvodje) and Lagurus-Podarcis sicula assemblage (Tatinja draga). Generally, at both localities the arid biocoenoses (steppe, stony landscape) were accompanied with mesophyllous areas, bushes and open landscape 8. References Alberdi, M.T., Caloi, L., & Palombo, M.R., 1998. Large mammal associations from the Early Pleistocene: Italy and Spain. Mededelingen Nederlands Instituut voor Toegepaste Geowetenschappen TNO, 60:521-532, Haarlem. B öhme, G., 1977. Zur Bestimmung quartärer Anuren Europas an Hand von Skelettelementen. Wiss. Z. Humboldt Univ., Mat.-Nat.R., 26:284-300, Berlin. Kormos, T., 1918. Die präglazialen Bildungen des Villanyer Gebirge und ihre Fauna. Jber. Ungar. Geol. Reichsanst., 1916/1, Budapest. Kormos, T., 1931. Über eine neuentdeckte Forest-Bed- Fauna in Dalmatien. Palaeobiologica, 4:113-136, Wien. Kowalski, K., 1958. Altpleistozäne Kleinsäugernfauna von Podumci in Norddalmatien. Palaeont. jugosl., 2:5-30, Zagreb. Malez, M., 1960. Paleontoloska istrazivanja i geoloska rekognosciranja u 1959. godini. Ljetopis Jugosl. akad. znan. umjetn., 66:309-324, Zagreb. M alez, M., 1968. K vartaroloska i speleoloska istrazivanja u 1965. godini. Ljetopis Jugosl. akad. znan. umjetn., 72:404-416, Zagreb. Malez, M., 1971. Izvjestaj o paleontoloskim i paleolitskim istrazi vanjima u 1968. godini. Ljetopis Jugosl. akad. znan. umjetn., 74:429-435, Zagreb. biotopes developed under temperate and periodically humid climatic conditions. Also, the existence of some running and/or stagnant waters is provable in the surroundings of both localities. The Allocricetus-Microtus-Lacerta agilis assemblage from Razvodje, as well as Lagurus-Podarcis sicula assemblage from Tatinja draga are characterized by a high percentage of steppe- and open landscape-dwelling taxa among small vertebrates. For both assemblages a high amount of thermophilous elements are characteristic as well as the presence of water-dwelling taxa among lower vertebrates. The described assemblages are similar to the fauna from Deutsch-Altenburg indicating a temperate climate and connection with the Central European faunal assemblages. In the same time they are similar with the Farneta faunal unit of Italy, as well as with the Southeastern European Tamanian faunas. High amount of genera still living in this area speaks in favour of the idea, that the fauna of the Adriatic coast and islands was formed during the Early Pleistocene. At the same time the frequency of endemic taxa reflects evolutionary changes of isolated populations depending on specific geologic, geographic as well as climatic alterations which were registered for the Quaternary of the described area. Malez, M. & Rabeder, G., 1984. Neues Fundmaterial von Kleinsäugem aus der altpleistozänen Spalten-füllung Podumci I in Norddalmatien (Kroatien, Jugoslawien). Beitr. Paläont. Osten., 8:1-373, Wien. Mrsic, N., 1978. Prispevek k poznavanju taksonomije, zoogeografije in ekologije plazilcev Velebita. Razprave Slov. akad. znan. umetn., 21/1:5-44, Ljubljana. N adachowski, A., 1998. Faunal succession of small mammal assemblages at the Plio-Pleistocene boundary in Poland. Mededelingen Nederlands Instituut voor Toegepaste Geowetenschappen TNO, 60:281-286, Haarlem. N ilsson T., 1983. The Pleistocene. Geology and Life in the Quaternary Ice Age. 651 pp., Enke Verlag, Stuttgart. Paunovic, M., 1984. Fische, Amphibien und Reptilien aus oberpleistozänen Ablagerungen von Sandalja bei Pula (Istrien, Kroatien). Palaeont. jugosl., 31:5-44, Zagreb. Paunovic, M., & Rabeder, G., 1996. Die altpleistozänen Kleinsäugerfaunen Razvodje und Tatinja draga in Süd- Kroatien. Beitr. Paläont. Österr., 21:69-84, Wien. Prelogovic, E., 1975. Neotektonska karta SR Hrvatske. Geol. vjesnik, 28:97-108, Zagreb. Rauscher, K.L., 1992. Die Echsen (Lacertilia, Reptilia) aus dem Plio-Pleistozän von Bad Deutsch-Altenburg, Niederösterreich. Beitr. Paläont. Österr., 17:81-177, Wien.

94 Beitr. Palaont., 25, Wien 2000 Rekovets, L., & Krakhmalnaya, T., 1998. The coincidence of stratigraphical boundaries and faunal events in the Early Pleistocene of southeastern Europe. Mededelingen Nederlands Instituut voor Teogepaste Geowetenschappen TNO, 60:339-342, Haarlem. Tvrtkovic, N., & Kletecki, E., 1993a. Preliminarna istrazivanja terestrickih kraljesnjaka Biokova. Acta biokovica, 6:11-18, Makarska. Tvrtkovic, N., & Kletecki, E., 1993b. Vertebrates of the Velebit Mountain (Croatia). Part 1: Amphibians. Nat. croat., 2/1:27-46, Zagreb. Szyndlar, Z., 1981. Early Pleistocene reptile fauna from Kozi Grzbiet in the Holy Cross Mts. Acta geol. polon., 31/1-2:81-101, Warszawa. received: February, 2000 accepted: April, 2000