Final report Jan 2009 to Oct 2014 V03

Similar documents
Ewes for the future fertility, lambs & wool

Ewes for the future. lambs, wool & profit. Section 2: Main results. Background. Comparing lambing percentages in ewe trials

Profitability of different ewe breeds Economic Analyses and Extension of Elmore Field Days Ewe Trials

Gross margins per hectare over 24 years

final report Sheep meat production systems Sheep meat production systems Project code: B.PRS.0705 / 2007/V02 Prepared by:

Multimeat x Merino. Composites Cashmore- Oaklea months Average ewe weight at joining, on 28Jan2016 includes

Time of lambing analysis - Crossbred Wagga NSW

Evaluating the performance of Dorper, Damara, Wiltshire Horn and Merino breeds in the low rainfall wheatbelt of Western Australia Tanya Kilminster

WOOL DESK REPORT MAY 2007

Lower body weight Lower fertility Lower fleece weight (superfine) (fine)

Sheep CRC Conference Proceedings

Managing to maximise lamb performance regardless of season. Doug Alcock

Implications of Lifetimewool for On-farm Management on the southern slopes (southern NSW & central Vic)

Table1. Target lamb pre-weaning daily live weight gain from grazed pasture

Impact of Scanning Pregnancy Status on farm profitability in South West Victoria

Flexibility in sheep systems lessons learnt from EverGraze research at Wagga/Tarcutta Michael Friend, CSU

The Goode Sheep. Merinos for the future. Henry Goode

EverGraze: pastures to improve lamb weaning weights

High sward height (6 cm) Weaning weight (kg) Drafted at weaning (%) Age at sale (days) Creep intake (kg)

Available from Deakin Research Online:

AN INITIATIVE OF. Wean More Lambs. Colin Trengove. Member SA Livestock Consultants EVENT PARTNERS: EVENT SUPPORTERS:

Lifetime Wool. Optimising ewe nutrition to increase farm profit

Breeding and feeding for more lambs. Andrew Thompson & Mark Ferguson

Extending the season for prime lamb production from grass

SA MERINO SIRE EVALUATION SITE TRIAL NEWS DECEMBER 2017

Implications of Lifetimewool for On-farm Management in South West Victoria

THE DOHNES ROLE IN THE AUSTRALIAN SHEEP INDUSTRY. Geoff Duddy, Sheep Solutions Leeton, NSW Australia

Ewe Management Handbook. Optimising Merino ewe nutrition to increase farm profit for southern slopes NSW and north central Victoria.

Ewe Management Handbook

HANDS ON EDUCATION - THE PRACTICAL ADVANTAGE. Robert Dunn

SHEEP HUSBANDRY AND WOOL TECHNOLOGY

Ewe Management Handbook. Optimising Merino ewe nutrition to increase farm profit for the high rainfall zone. lifetimewool

Like to see more lambs?

1 of 9 7/1/10 2:08 PM

Cotter Suffolks and White Suffolks, with Wongarra Poll Dorsets

Achieving fat score targets: the costs and benefits

Sheep Electronic Identification. Nathan Scott Mike Stephens & Associates

7. IMPROVING LAMB SURVIVAL

The Right Lamb Every Time

The change in the New Zealand flock and its performance

AUTUMN AND SPRING-LAMBING OF MERINO EWES IN SOUTH-WESTERN VICTORIA

Wean more lambs. John Webb Ware Mackinnon Project University of Melbourne

Crossbreeding to Improve Productivity ASI Young Entrepreneur Meeting. David R. Notter Department of Animal and Poultry Sciences Virginia Tech

COST FACTORS IN PRACTICAL FAT LAMB PRODUCTION ByJ.H. SNEVD*

Inaugural On-Farm Stud Ram & Commercial Ewe Sale

Ewe Management Handbook. Optimising Merino ewe nutrition to increase farm profit for the cereal-sheep zone. lifetimewool

Challenges and opportunities facing the Australian wool industry

AN INITIATIVE OF Mo.llll\ More Fro?M Sheep. Grow 10% more wool Achieve 10% more carcase value Produce 10% more lambs per hectare HAMILTON, VICTORIA

Key Information. Mountain Hill Vs Lowland Production. Breeding Strategy

North South. Ram Sale

Crops were generally sown late April mid May as per district practice to set a baseline. This was compared with three scenarios.

SHEEP. Finishing hill lambs Latest Teagasc research on finishing hill lambs on autumn pastures and on an all-concentrate diet.

AN INITIATIVE OF. The New Ewe. Andrew Kennedy EVENT PARTNERS: EVENT SUPPORTERS:

INFLUENCE OF FEED QUALITY ON THE EXPRESSION OF POST WEANING GROWTH ASBV s IN WHITE SUFFOLK LAMBS

Finishing lambs from grazed pasture The options and the facts. Dr. Tim Keady

Crossbred ewe performance in the Welsh hills

Amoilla. Burrabogie. Wargam. Willurah

SA MERINO SIRE EVALUATION TRIAL - UPDATE

South Australian Schools' merino Wethers Competition Handbook

Monthly Economic Review November 2017

Reasons for an Autumn Lambing Programme in the Western District of Victoria

NSIP EBV Notebook June 20, 2011 Number 2 David Notter Department of Animal and Poultry Sciences Virginia Tech

SHEEP SIRE REFERENCING SCHEMES - NEW OPPORTUNITIES FOR PEDIGREE BREEDERS AND LAMB PRODUCERS a. G. Simm and N.R. Wray

Annual On-Property Ram Sale

Crossbred lamb production in the hills

SHEEPGENETICS HEALTH

At Pooginook we provide advanced Merino genetics and wool marketing options for the wool industry. About Pooginook

An assessment of the benefits of utilising Inverdale-carrying texel-type rams to produce crossbred sheep within a Welsh context

Maximising subterranean clover in Marlborough s hill country is key to weaning 80% of sale lambs prime

The wool production and reproduction of Merino ewes can be predicted from changes in liveweight during pregnancy and lactation

Dryland Pastoral Research at Ashley Dene

GROWTH OF LAMBS IN A SEMI-ARID REGION AS INFLUENCED BY DISTANCE WALKED TO WATER

10/3/2016. NRC reqt s for Replacement Ewes. Developing Replacement Ewe Lambs. Differences in Feeding Market Lambs vs Replacement Ewe Lambs

Improving sheep welfare for increased production

Don Pegler and John Keiller

Late pregnancy nutrition the key to flock profitability

Improving efficiencies in small scale sheep production Welcome

7. Flock book and computer registration and selection

International sheep session Focus on Iceland Eyþór Einarsson 1, Eyjólfur I. Bjarnason 1 & Emma Eyþórsdóttir 2 1

The Power of NSIP to Increase Your Profits. August 17, 2015 Rusty Burgett, Program Director

Sale Catalogue: Friday, Oct

Optimising Worm Control in Prime Lamb Flocks in South Western NSW

BETTER SHEEP BREEDING Ram buying decisions

Breech Strike Genetics

To feed or to not to feed? More results coming soon

Proof of Concept Lean Meat Yield and Eating Quality Producer Demonstration Sites

Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding

Ram Buyers Guide.

Extended grazing its potentials and limitations

The effect of weaning weight on subsequent lamb growth rates

Live assessment yard book

Management strategies to improve lamb weaning percentages

PRODUCTION MARKET LAMB BREEDING OTTAWA - CANADA FOR. utltmbtk PUBLICATION 865 OTTAWA S. B. WILLIAMS PROPERTY OF LIBRARY DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,

Nutritional management for reproductive efficiency

Level 1 Agricultural and Horticultural Science, 2017

Keeping and Using Flock Performance Records Debra K. Aaron, Animal and Food Sciences

Extra. Feed planning for ewes in late pregnancy and early lactation, during the housed period. Take a stepped approach to feed planning.

Richard Ehrhardt, Ph.D. Sheep and Goat Extension Specialist Michigan State University

Genetic approaches to improving lamb survival under extensive field conditions

Assessment Schedule 2017 Subject: Agricultural and Horticultural Science: Demonstrate knowledge of livestock management practices (90921)

Transcription:

Final report Jan 29 to Oct 214 V3 Page 1 of 52

Trial committee & contact details Ged McCormick Chairman sheep committee 418 55 345 EFD (3) 5432 6176 info@elmorefielddays.com.au Elmore Events Centre Rosaia Road Elmore Vic 3558 Max Williams Ewe trial committee 428 341 667 Home (3) 5436 9254 167 Minto Road, Drummartin Raywood Vic 357 Roger Trewick Ewe trial committee 428 326 19 Home (3) 5432 619 peperton@bigpond.net.au Pepperton Minto Road Elmore Vic 3558 Athol Frederick Landmark Bendigo Work (3) 5448 3881 428 51 518 athol.frederick@landmark.com.au Landmark 148 Midland Hwy Epsom Vic 3551 Kieran Ransom formerly DPI Bendigo 419 32 824 Home (3) 5443 1871 kieran.ransom@bigpond.com 19 Neale St Bendigo Vic 355 Note The Elmore Field Days sheep trials committee need to script read results before they are passed on to the media by participating groups. They are concerned that selected information may be used out of context without presenting the full situation and results. When breed groups use the results in their promotions it is expected the Elmore Field Days will be acknowledged. The trial is run by the Elmore Field Days in cooperation with the Campaspe Lamb Producers Group. Pictured at lamb marking are Pat Johnson, Roger Kemp, David Lees, Peter Safstrom, Erica Schelfhorst, Frank Oliver, Max Williams, Bill Johnson, Glen Rathjen, Rod Fiedler, Ged McCormick, Kieran Ransom and Rob Williamson. Disclaimer This publication may be of assistance to you but the Elmore Field Days and its volunteers and employees do not guarantee that the publication is without flaw of any kind or is wholly appropriate for your particular purposes and therefore disclaims all liability for any error, loss or other consequence which may arise from you relying on any information in this publication. Page 2 of 52

Contents page Section 1: Section 2: Section 3: Summary Background and method.... 4 Differences between teams and breeds Comparing lambing percentages in ewe trials The Elmore environment Statistical analyses Results....... 6 Ewe weight & condition score Lambing as ewe lambs Lambing as adults Seasonality of breeding season Lamb weights and dressing percentage Wool DSE estimate Lamb, wool & skin returns Profitability Results in detail Background...... 13 Management 14 Delivery to the site Management The Elmore environment Statistical analyses..... 15 Ewe weight and condition score... 16 Lambing details..... 17 Comparing lambing percentage in ewe trials Lambing 5 year averages Lambing each year Seasonality of breeding Additional scanning details Cause of lamb death Lamb weight and carcase.... 28 Lamb weight and dressing percentage Lamb growth each year Wool....... 33 Weight Yield Fibre diameter Wool price and returns Additional measurements on mid side samples Bale core and grab sample measurements Visual scores on wool and sheep... 39 Fleece rot score Wool greasy colour score Skin wrinkle score Face cover score Teeth at end of trial Total returns from lamb & wool, DSE estimate.. 42 Lamb and wool returns DSE estimate Profitability Additional details by team and breed Additional results by team and breed... 47 Ewe weight Ewe condition score Pregnancy scanning Clean fleece weight Fibre diameter Page 3 of 52

Section 1: Summary Background and method What s the best sheep type for a combination of prime lamb and wool production? This question has been debated by sheep producers for years. In January 29, the Elmore Field Days trial, Ewes for the Future Lambs, Wool and Profit, began. The trial aims to compare the merits of five alternative sheep types in the Northern Victorian environment at Elmore. The results will assist sheep producers determine the merits of a number of ewe breed alternatives for prime lamb and wool production. The main characters of interest are lambing percentages, lamb growth rates and wool production. The ewe breed types are: x cross. The most common prime lamb mother in northern Victoria. Ewes were sourced with the help of the $uperborder$ group, a group within the breed society using Australian Sheep Breeding Values (ASBVs) to help breed better rams.,. The second most common prime lamb mother in northern Victoria. The sheep are mostly based on Peppin bloodlines with some influence from South Australian bloodlines. Ewes were sourced with the help of the Stud Breeders Association.. is a group breeding scheme and registered merino stud and in Central West NSW that aims to produce dual purpose sheep. This strain has achieved a good reputation from the high dual purpose and fine wool index ASBVs on the Sheep Genetics Australia website.. The is a dual-purpose breed developed in South Africa using Peppin type ewes and German Mutton sires. They have been selected for high fertility, rapid lamb growth rate and fine wool. There is a high level of farmer interest in this dualpurpose breed. Sheep were sourced with the assistance of the Australian Breeders Association. In 28 the breed was in the early stages of introduction to Australia. Two properties supplied F2 ewe lambs while the third property supplied F3s. See note below.. The Prime (South African Meat ) is a dual-purpose sheep originally bred in South Africa to produce heavy slaughter lambs at a young age as well as good quality wool. The breed society is aiming at 6 per cent meat and 4 per cent wool in members breeding programs. Sheep were sourced with the assistance of the Prime Breeders Society of Australia. In 28 the breed was in the early stages of introduction to Australia. Two properties supplied F3 ewe lambs while the third property supplied a mix of F2s and F3s. Note: F1 is the first cross, a F2 is a second cross and a F3 is a third cross when introducing a new breed. At the start of the trial, a total of 21 ewe lambs were delivered to the site. The five breed-types are each represented by 42 ewes. Each breed type group was randomly selected from three properties, with 14 ewe lambs per property after an allowance for culling. Ewe lambs, 28 drop were delivered to the Elmore Field Days by early January 29. They were fed a high-quality diet to reach a suitable joining weight in late February 29, when they were joined to White Suffolk rams. They were run together for 6 lambings, the first as ewe lambs, with the exception of lambing in separate paddocks by breed group each year. The table below shows key management dates. Lambing Seasonal year Ewe age at lambing Join date Mid lambing date Date first batch of lambs sold Shearing date 1 st 29 15 mths 26 Feb 29 12 Aug 1 Feb 21 6-8 Oct 2 nd 21 2 yrs 28 Dec 29 13 Jun 5 Nov 21 5-7 Oct 3 rd 211 3 yrs 1 Dec 21 12 May 2 Oct 211 4-6 Oct 4 th 212 4 yrs 1 Feb 212 12 Jul 22 Oct 212 2-4 Oct 5 th 213 5 yrs 1 Feb 213 12 Jul 1 Dec 213 1-3 Oct 6 th 214 6 yrs 1 Nov 214 18 Apr 11 Sep 214 7-9 Oct Differences between teams and breeds Are the ewes in the trial representative of the breed group? Ewes representing each breed were sourced from 3 properties because of the genetic variability between flocks within a breed. All ewe lambs in this study came from flocks nominated by breed society representatives and in many cases they were present at selection. Sheep breeds are composed of many bloodlines, there are genetic differences between bloodlines, flocks within bloodlines as well as individuals in an individual flock. For example, the breed covers a wide range of types from those with a focus on very fine wool to those with a focus on dual purpose meat and wool characters. These results therefore, only apply to the sheep at Elmore and they may or may not be truly representative of the breeds in general. There were sometimes significant differences in body weight and wool between teams within a breed group. These results are shown in the detail section of this report. Page 4 of 52

Comparing lambing percentages in ewe trials Trials at Trangie by the NSW Dept Agriculture found big differences between bloodlines in lambing percentages when all ewes were reared together from conception to the end of the trial. Similar differences no doubt exist in other breeds. However issues arising from ewe trials comparing lambing percentages include: (i) Does the level of nutrition in early life as a foetus, as young lamb up to weaning and from weaning until entry to this trial, affect mature body size, wool production and lambing percentages later in life? Overall, Australian and New Zealand research, in four trials with merino sheep, indicate the nutrition of the young merino ewe, from a foetus to weaning has zero or at most small long term effects on subsequent reproduction under commercial farm conditions. However, two trials in Britain with local breeds indicated that under nutrition as a young lamb lowered lambs born per ewe joined by around 4 to 5%. It was suggested this was due to a higher rate of embryo or foetal mortality during pregnancy rather than differences in dry ewes or number of eggs shed per ewe. (ii) How does hybrid vigour affect lambing percentage?. Hybrid vigour is well known in x cross ewes. What is less known is the hybrid vigour when strains are crossed. NSW Dept Agriculture research conducted from 1975 to 2 indicated when bloodlines were crossed the average values of ewe or maternal hybrid vigour, expressed through a ewe being a pure bloodline or cross bloodline, were 1.2% for fertility (wet versus dry ewes), 2.9% for litter size (singles, twins or triplets), 6.8% for lamb survival and 8.2% for lambs weaned. These NSW Dept Agriculture merinos were initially purchased in the early 197s when merino bloodlines were more defined than present day merino studs as artificial insemination and the use of rams from other studs may have reduced differences between these traditional bloodlines. Reviews of research worldwide indicate average hybrid vigour of 14% in number of lambs weaned when any two breeds are crossed. This may have implications for s and s where the studs have used rams from diverse sources for many years. It may also have effects when South African origin breeds are crossed with Australian s. The F1 cross would be expected to have the most hybrid vigour in reproduction. The hybrid vigour component of extra reproduction would be expected to halve in the F2 generation and halve again in the F3 generation. (iii) Some breeds, especially x cross are regarded to be more seasonal breeders than say s. The choice of lambing time may thus put some breeds at an advantage or disadvantage to others. (iv) Lambing management, for example not separating singles or twins after pregnancy scanning within each breed group, might disadvantage breeds with a higher percentage of twins. Overall the standard of lambing management in this trial was very high; lambing ewes were usually inspected twice per day. (v) The ewes in the trial were first joined as ewe lambs. The question then arises: What effect did lambing as a ewe lamb have on lambing in the following years? Did lambing as ewe lambs penalise those ewes so they had a lower lambing percentage the following year? An analysis of this trial indicated that lambing as a ewe lamb had no deleterious effects on lambing percentages in subsequent years. Several other trials have given similar results. The Elmore environment The ewes were run on the Elmore Field Days site 3 km east of Elmore in northern Victoria. The long term average rainfall is 466 mm. The rain is winter dominant. Most sheep grazing is on annual pastures growing between late autumn and spring and dry pasture residues and crop stubbles over the summer. Annual crops of cereals, oilseeds and grain legumes are normally sown in late autumn and harvested in early summer. Summer storms in some years provide extra green feed from dry-land lucerne and green summer weeds. The trial sheep mostly grazed annual green pasture in the winter spring growing season and dry pasture and crop residues in the summer. There was some dry-land lucerne that provided additional summer feed. An area of irrigated annual winter pasture was watered up each autumn. This provided some extra feed in the difficult late autumn period. The wet summers, especially the 21-11 summer provided additional summer green feed from weeds. At times of feed scarcity sheep were provided with a grain supplement or silage. The rainfall over the trial period is shown below. Rain at Elmore during the trial period Year Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTAL 29 22 31 12 5 52 29 36 29 5 13 325 21 33 83 6 51 48 32 55 13 47 92 88 84 777 211 134 11 54 49 14 18 41 64 4 16 63 18 62 212 28 88 14 18 15 38 52 3 23 22 7 14 438 213 3 36 17 2 25 46 59 55 51 17 9 38 358 214 6 14 49 78 35 86 29 5 52 9 4 27 429 Long term average 31 28 31 33 44 48 47 47 44 45 37 32 466 Statistical analyses Statistical analyses of these results were conducted by Forbes Brien and Wayne Pitchford from the University of Adelaide with financial support from Australian Wool Innovation. These averages are shown with Least Significant Difference where appropriate. Page 5 of 52

Results Ewe weight & condition score Ewe weights from birth (birth weights were assumed at 5kg, birth dates obtained for each group) to current. This graphs indicates the lambs were born over a four month and the early drop lambs were heavier at the first complete weighing on 8 th January 29. The lambs continued to gain weight on their supplements after arrival. The aim of feeding over the first year was to steadily grow all the lambs out to maturity and ensure that there was no permanent disadvantage over the length of the trial. Ewe weights (fleece free) from birth on farms of origin and at Elmore from 8Jan9 to 9Oct14. Ewe weight kg 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 The lines indicate the average weight of each group over time. A birth weight of 5kg was assumed for all teams. The average birth date was determined after discussions with the breeder of each team. x, Ewe weight at joining, average 5 adult joinings kg 1 8 6 4 2 79.6 x cross Least significant different difference between any two breeds is 8.1 kg (P=.5) 63.6, 7.7 7.6 79.7 Ewe condition score at joining, average 5 adult joinings CS Least significant different difference between any two breeds is.17 CS (P=.5) 5 4 3 2 1 4.34 x cross 3.55 3.77, 4.5 4.38 Page 6 of 52

Lambing as ewe lambs The sheep were initially joined as ewe lambs after they had been run together six weeks. Ewe lambs ability to get in lamb is governed by their age, weight and condition, all a function of their original farm environment. Twenty five lambs were considered too light to join as they weighed under 4 kg ( 19 and 6). The lambing results from unjoined lambs are not included in the figure below. This graph indicates that provided ewe lambs can reach a suitable weight, condition score and age, then good lambings are possible. Lambing details 29, joined as ewe lambs Joining 26 Feb, Preg scan 27 May, Mid lambing 12 Aug. Lambs marked 12% 1% 15% 8% 6% 4% 2% % x cross Ewe wt 55 kg Cond Scr 4. Age 9.7 mths 44% Ewe wt 43 kg Cond Scr 3.3 Age 1.1 mths 52% Ewe wt 44 kg Cond Scr 3.2 Age 7.7 mths Ewe weight, condition score and age at joining 83% Ewe wt 51 kg Cond Scr 3.9 Age 1.4 mths 74% Ewe wt 52 kg Cond Scr 4. Age 1.1 mths Lambing as adults The figure below averages the 5 years of adult lamb marking percentages, but does not include the first year when ewe lambs were joined six weeks after arrival at Elmore. As discussed elsewhere; the nutrition in early life and lambing as ewe lambs probably had minimal effects on lambing performance after one year of running together. Lambs marked, percent, average over 5 adult lambings Percent 14% 12% 1% 8% 6% 4% 2% % 132% x cross Least significant different difference between any two breeds is 6% (P=.5) 96% 116% 96% 132% The average (i) pregnancy scanning rate, (ii) lambs born and (iii) lambs marked over five adult lambings Percent 18% 16% 14% 12% 1% 8% 6% 4% 2% % 157% 15% 132% x cross Least significant different differences between any two breeds are (P=.5) Pregnancy scanning rate - 18% Lambs born - 9% Lambs marked - 6% 129% 116% 96% 148% 138% 116% 126% 12% 96% Preg scan rate Lambs born Lambs marked 132% 156% 16% Page 7 of 52

Lambs born/ewe joined %. Ewes for the future Number of lambs born and its relation to ewe weight at joining The lines indicate the relationship between the number of lambs born and ewe weight at joining for three lambing times for x ewes in an experiment at Rutherglen in the 197s. The dots are Elmore data and indicate the average ewe weight and average number of lambs born for each breed over the five adult lambings. The least significant difference of lambs born is 9%, thus if the dots overlap there is no significant difference between the measurements, if the dots do not overlap then the differences are real or significant. 2% 19% 18% 17% 16% 15% 14% 13% 12% 11% 1% 9% 8% 7% 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% % August lambing June-July lambing May lambing LV CP Mer BLxMer 45 5 55 6 65 7 75 8 85 9 Ewe weight at joining, fleece free kg Seasonality of breeding season Most sheep in Australia are seasonal breeders. They join more readily in the autumn that late spring to early summer. However the breeds differ in their seasonality of breeding. x (BL x M ) cross ewes are well known to be more seasonal breeders than merinos. For example in a trial at Rutherglen in the 197s ewes at 7 kg weight and lambing in May would be expected to lamb down at 115% lambs born per ewe joined. Ewes lambing 4 months later in August at the same weight would be expected to lamb at 19%, an increase of 75% (see graph below). This conclusion was reached by a six year trial with ewes running at several stocking rates with three times of lambing over a 6 year. This Elmore trial was not designed to compare the seasonality of breeding season between the ewe groups. Lambing percentages are influenced by many factors including ewe condition score, live weight, nutrition around joining time, nutrition 4 to 6 months before joining as well as the seasonality of the breeding season. In this trial the numbers of ewes is also limited. Statistical analyses of this trial are thus unable to reach conclusions, but we can still look for trends that indicate BL x M ewes might be more seasonal breeders than the other breeds. In the table below the BL x M cross ewes had a 35% increase in lambs born. They were joined late (26 Feb) once as ewe lambs with 15% lambs marked, however comparisons are not possible as the ewe lambs were only together 6 weeks prior to this joining. However there seems to be a trend that confirms other research that indicates BL x M ewes reach their full potential with a March April joining. The figure below shows the average lambs born and ewe weight relationship of the ewes in this trial sorted by the three early and two later adult joinings. Table indicating the lambs born per ewe joined for three earlier joinings and two later joinings. Ewes were on average about 1 kg heavier as well as being older at the later joinings, see graph below. Breed Three earlier joinings Two later joinings Increase in lambs born from the early to later joinings x cross 136% 171% 35%, 11% 125% 15% 129% 153% 24% 114% 129% 14% 148% 167% 18% The BL x M ewes, more seasonal breeders than merinos, had higher lambing percentages with the 2 later lambings, a 35% increase, compared to the other breeds that showed an 18% increase. Page 8 of 52

Lambs born/ewe joined %. Ewes for the future Number of lambs born and its relation to ewe weight at joining for 'early' and 'later' lambings. The lines indicate the relationship between lambs born and ewe weight at joining for three lambing times for x ewes in an experiment at Rutherglen in the 197s. The dots are Elmore data and indicate the ewe weight and number of lambs born for each breed. There were five lambings. Three lambings were 'early' and two lambings were 'later'. 2% 19% 18% 17% 16% 15% 14% 13% 12% 11% 1% 9% 8% 7% 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% % June-July lambing August lambing May lambing BLxMer LV CP Mer 45 5 55 6 65 7 75 8 85 9 Ewe weight at joining, fleece free kg Early joining, Thin borders, join on 28Dec for 21 lambing 1Dec for 211 1Nov for 214 Later joining, Thick borders, join on 1Feb for 212 lambings 1Feb for 213 Lamb weights and dressing percentage Lambs reared as singles or twins could not be identified in this trial. Other research indicates twin lambs grow from 12 to 2% slower than single lambs to weaning. Thus breeds with higher lambing percentages and a higher number of twins would have a twin lamb growth penalty. Lamb weight of all lambs before any sales, average over 5 adult lambings 5 4 3 2 1 kg 47.7 x cross Least significant different difference between any two breeds is is.5 kg (P=.5) 44.3 46.1 46.3 48.5, Ewes penned for regular management work Page 9 of 52

Lamb weight gain from marking until the first lambs were sold, average over 5 adult lambings 3 25 2 15 1 5 grams/day 261 x cross Least significant different difference between any two breed s is 3 grams/day (P=.5) 241, 258 255 274 Lamb dressing percentage, average of four batches measured 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% % Percent 47.2% 46.4% 46.7% 47.1% 47.4% x cross Least significant different difference between any two breeds is.3% (P=.5), Lamb live weight produced per ewe, average over 5 adult lambings kg 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 63. x cross The lamb live weight per ewe is calculated from the average lamb weight and lamb marking percentage 42.6, 53.4 44.6 64.2 Wool Growing and rearing a lamb can reduce greasy fleece weight by up to one kg. It will also affect fibre diameter and wool tensile strength. Thus ewes with higher lambing percentages will have a larger fleece weight penalty and other wool changes. Some breeds will also put more energy into their milk supply and growing the lamb, thus ewes rearing faster growing lambs will also have a larger wool penalty. Clean fleece weight, average of 5 adult shearings CFW, kg/head 6 5 4 3 2 1 3.97 x cross Least significant different difference between any two breeds is.38 kg (P=.5) 4.84, 4.12 3.53 2.66 Page 1 of 52

Greasy fleece weight, average 5 adult shearings 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 kg 5.48 x cross 6.62, Least significant different difference between any two breeds is.52 kg (P=.5) 5.95 5.9 4.7 Fleece wool yield, average 5 adult shearings percent 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 The fleece yield each year is the average of the mid side samples and the bale core test 72.4 74.3 x cross, Least significant different difference between any two breeds is.6 pct (P=.5) 7. 71.1 66.3 Fibre diameter, average 5 adult shearings um 35 3 25 2 15 1 5 DSE estimate 3.3 x cross Least significant different difference between any two breeds is 1.3 um (P=.5) 2.9, 19. Sheep feed needs were converted to Dry Sheep Equivalent (DSE) to account for the weight of the ewe and lambing percentage. Larger sheep with higher lambing percentages have higher feed needs. One DSE is the amount of feed energy needed to maintain a 5 kg dry sheep for one year. It roughly equates to about 35 to 5 kg of pasture eaten by a sheep. The kilogram of feed needed varies with pasture quality. One DSE of high quality pasture, with green for 8 months and dry residues for 4 months may equate to about 38 kg eaten while low quality dry pasture for most of the year may equate to about 5 kg. The DSE per ewe and lamb unit is calculated for each breed considering the average ewe weight, lambing percentage and the lamb growth rate with the help of the CSIRO GrazFeed program. One DSE (1. DSE) is assumed to be a 5 kg dry sheep maintaining weight. If a dry sheep weighs 7 kg its DSE rating is 1.28 DSE. If a 5 kg ewe raises a single lamb to 3 months in a normal year its DSE rating is 1.68. A 5 kg dry ewe will have a DSE rating of 1. and a ewe rearing twins will have a higher DSE rating. The DSE rating of a lamb from weaning at 3 months to sale is also added. For example if a lamb grows from 33 kg at 3 months to 54 kg at 5.5 months it is growing at 28 grams a day; its DSE rating is 2.15 on a daily basis but on a year average basis it is.54 DSE. The DSE for each breed ewe-lamb combination, assuming all lambs are sold at 5.5 months, is shown below. 2.8 24.4 DSE per ewe-lamb unit, average 5 adult lambings DSE/ewe-lamb unit 4 3 2 1 3.7 2.21 2.62 2.42 3.6 x cross, Page 11 of 52

Lamb, wool & skin returns Wool returns were calculated each year using average wool prices for each diameter and type over the previous 12 months. Lamb returns are calculated each year from the live weight, dressing percentage and skin value. Skins were priced using average values from the MLA Weekly Price Report. No discount has been applied to the possibly slightly more wrinkled skins from the terminal sire x merino type lambs. Discounts for more wrinkled merino cross skins could be in the region from nil to $2 per skin. The 5 year average is shown in the graph below Lamb and wool returns, average 5 years as adults Lamb returns per head include an adjustment for lambing percentage $/ewe $2 $18 $16 $14 $12 $1 $8 $6 $4 $2 $ $19.94 $154.54 x cross $52.96 $12.32, $49.67 $13.4 $38.7 $18.68 Wool returns Lamb returns $23.17 $157.8 Profitability Profitability comparisons of terminal sires joined to alternative ewe breeds are complex. It is invalid to estimate the relative profitability of breed groups by dividing the total returns per ewe by the DSE rating as it does not take into account the monthly pasture growth, feed available on a monthly basis, stocking rate, the feed needs of the sheep and the ability of alternative systems to manage droughts and unpredictable prices. Gross margins analyses of these systems will be done using the CSIRO GrassGro computer program a program that can better estimate the profitability of these dynamic systems over a range of years of variable rainfall, prices, stocking rates and management systems. For example at lower stocking rates there may be little feed stress penalty from large framed ewes with high lambing percentages; while at higher stocking rates lamb growth may be penalised. The higher wool returns from merinos will also be important when drought affected young lambs are sold at low weights and drought prices. In this Elmore trial all sheep enterprises have the same structure;- purchased ewes joined to terminal sires. But not all sheep farms buy in replacement ewes. Farms with self replacing flocks often have three alternative meat and wool combinations of income. These are: (i) (ii) (iii) Ewes joined to terminal sires Replacement ewes rearing wether lambs Replacement ewes rearing replacement ewe lambs These three sub-enterprises will have different contributions to the profitability of the whole flock. This trial only compares the first enterprise, ewes joined to terminal sires. Flock structure is affected by lambing percentage. The higher the lambing percentage the higher the proportion joined to terminal sires. Farms with average lambing percentages can only join up to 25% of their ewes to terminals, while farms with high lambing percentages can join over 5% to terminals. The next question is; what is the profitability of a ewe rearing a wether lamb? In a merino flock this will depend on (i) the wether lambs ability to grow quickly, (ii) the wool returns when it is shorn just prior to the lamb sale and (iii) the discount per kilo for merino wether lambs (or pure other breeds) relative to terminal sire prime lambs. Other demonstration-trials, such as the Peter Westblade Memorial Meat Challenge in southern NSW can help show between bloodline differences in wether lamb growth. Farmer observations in North Central Victoria indicate large framed dual purpose s can reach market weights of 54 kg at about 11 months of age on lucerne pasture in normal years, while wool focused s will take 14 to 15 months to reach a similar weight. Page 12 of 52