ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE. Defendants
|
|
- Phoebe Dickerson
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE CITATION: Wiens v. Mino, 2018 ONSC 3234 COURT FILE NO.: CV A1 DATE: BETWEEN: HAYDEN WIENS by his litigation guardian, KRIS WIENS, KRIS WIENS and Annette A. Casullo, for the Plaintiffs ERIN WIENS Plaintiffs - and - ALLAN MINO and LAURIE MINO - and - Defendants Ryan D. Truax, for the Defendants DEBBIE LIVINGSTON Jason G. Arcuri, for the Third Party Third Party M. P. EBERHARD [1] The Third Party moves for Summary Judgment dismissing the claim against her brought by the Defendants alleging that her negligence contributed to the injury to the child Hay den from the Defendants' dog Murdock on April 18, 2014 when Hay den was 2 years and 10 months of age. [2] The Defendants, are liable by section 2(1 of the Dog Owner's Liability Act. I will hereafter refer to Allan Mino as the owner as it was he who was present and he who supplies the Defendants' evidence. [3] The Defendants claim that the Third Party, the child's Grandma, may be found at least 1% liable, by a properly instructed jury, based on subsection 2(4 of the Dog Owner's Liability Act which states: An owner who is liable to pay damages under this section is entitled to recover contribution and indemnity from any other person in proportion to the degree to which the other person's fault or negligence caused or contributed to the damages.
2 2 [4] The incident took place while Hayden was out walking in his Grandma's neighbourhood under his Grandma's care. [5] Grandma was walking her older dog. Allan Mino had his young golden retriever Murdock by the collar as the adults spoke near the end of his driveway. [6] There is a factual dispute between the owner and the Grandma as to whether Hayden was by her side as the owner crouched beside his dog during the conversation or approached from behind the owner towards the adults who were in conversation introducing the dogs to each other. [7] If, as the Grandma states, Hayden was quietly at her side when the incident occurred, there can be no assertion she was negligent. [8] [9] If Hayden was not at her side, there is dispute whether she had left the child "unattended" so as to constitute negligence. Counsel are not in dispute as to the nature of Summary Judgment. If it is to be granted based on a finding of fact it would necessarily be under the expanded powers now legislated and recognized in Hryniak' and subsequent. The two versions really are not reconcilable so I do not proceed on that basis. Rather, I will analyze the owner's testimony asserting facts upon which it is claimed the Grandma's negligence may have contributed to the incident. His testimony puts "his best foot forward" as traditional Summary Judgment analysis contemplates. [10] I state at the outset, that this injury which resulted, in what the owner could not distinguish was from a nip or a scratch by the dog, arose out of the most commonplace and benign neighbourhood interaction. Discussion here of strict liability and negligence does not elevate this activity to malevolence or indifference. [11] By whichever version or splicing of versions of the factual accounts, a child straying from his Grandma's side onto neighbourhood lawns on their walk of itself raises no spectre of negligence. A dog owner bending beside his dog whose collar is in his grasp, managing the introduction between the two dogs, is prudent and amiable. A boisterous young dog straining against being held by the collar need not even be characterized as aggressive. But lunging can nevertheless cause some harm. Both the owner and the Grandma describe that the dog lunged. [12] [13] The owner's liability arises out of a legislated policy likely made necessary by just such occurrences as this, where everyone is behaving appropriately, but a dog acts suddenly to create some misadventure. So be it. That is our legislated context. It leaves the only question one of the sufficiency of the Grandma's supervision in the circumstances. Hryniak v Mauldin [2014 SCC7
3 3 [14] As indicated, if the Grandma's evidence is accepted there is no viable suggestion of negligence. However on this motion for Summary Judgment, the untested assertions of the owner and the Grandma cannot be reconciled so I limit my consideration to whether there is a triable issue if the owner's evidence is accepted. [15] I find the owner cannot take comfort from the case law cited. In Sgro 2 the parent was found 25% liable as he left his child unattended with a German Sheppard dog of unknown propensities. In that case the father had gone behind a building such that the child and unrestrained dog were out of his sight. [16] That is highly distinguishable from the present circumstance where the two adults were standing together and the owner had his dog by the collar and was bending to manage the introduction of his dog to the Grandma's older dog. This was exactly the sort of control that the Grandma would be expected to be alert for to assess the danger the dog might present and quite appropriate for her to rely on the owner's control. [17] The owner asserts that the child approached from somewhere on his lawn and came into the dogs vicinity. Counsel suggests that the Grandma was negligent in allowing the child away from her side, speculating that she was providing insufficient protection against the child bolting in front of a car or, as asserted here, approaching a dog. [18] In Ontario we leash dogs, not children. There is no ten foot standard as suggested by counsel. While the owner claims he did not see the child until he was approaching down the slope of his lawn, he did see him coming. Even in his version of what happened there is no reason to suppose the Grandma was not attentive to the movements of the child on the lawn, even as the child approached the near circle with the collared dog, two adults and a known docile dog. The merest opportunity to intervene might have arisen as the child approached, to warn the child to stay back from the boisterous young dog, though he was held by his master, or the merest chance to possibly insert herself between them. [19] Dogs and children do unexpected actions in the blink of an eye. Not acting on the merest opportunity to avoid a dog's action that seemed to be, and was intended to be, controlled by its master's direct conduct of holding its collar is highly distinguishable from walking to the far side of a building out of site as in Sgro. [20] I turn to the owner's testimony given on examinations: 129 Q: When did you first see Hay den, who was the little boy? A: When the dog - when he ran down the hill to the dog. 130 Q: What hill are you speaking about? A: From the top of our grass down to the driveway. 141Q: You don't know where he came from? A: Before I saw him no, I don't know where he was. But he wasn't with the dog and grandma because the street is straight and as 2 Sgro v Verbeek 1980 CarswellOnt
4 4 they're walking along you can see who is there. So he wasn't with grandma or the dog. 142 Q: I see there's vehicles in the 142 Q: Yeah, there wasn't when the day that it happened 145 Q: That's when you knelt down with Murdock? A: That's when I stopped and knelt down and held him close to me, so that their dog could be introduced to him. 151 Q: Did you warn them that Murdock wasn't tied up? A: No, I had him so he was contained, so there was no problem with the other dog. This other -her dog was old so they just usually looked at each other when they when Abbey and the old dog looked they just didn't really get too excited about it. So, I just wanted to make sure if she came to explore who Abbey or who Murdock was, that you know, I had control of him. 153 Q: Why don't you describe to me what you remember about the actual bite itself? A: Well, it happened so quick I didn't even know whether it was a bite or whether it was a paw mark. So, it was just the chap came down the hill and I had Murdock. And Murdock was so excited he just raised up, lunged, whatever you want to call it. And that resulted in something on his cheek. He was covered up pretty good and grandmother freaked out, Debbie, you said her name was. And 154 Q: Sorry, so you said it was covered up pretty good? I don't know what that means. A: Well, everybody was like you know, in- like I had the dog so they all went like he had hurt himself Q: Was Murdock ever out of your A: no. 157 Q: You held Murdock during the bite? A: Consistently. 159 Q: Did you pull Murdock off Hayden? He was it was just a flash encounter. When the damage was done, it was like he wasn't on him. The lunge cause the incident. But as I say, it was so fast I didn't even know at the time whether it was a paw or whether it was he nipped him. 160 Q: Can you say how far away Hayden was from Murdock when it happened?
5 5 A: Two feet, but he was running down so the incident sort of like stopped him. 161 Q; Did you yell at Hay den to stop running? A: No, I had the dog. 162 Q: Did Hayden do anything to provoke the bite? A; Except run at him, run at Murdock. 163 Q: How do you know he was running at Murdock and not maybe running to his Grandma? A: Well, everybody was in the same vicinity. So, whether it was Grandma or Murdock or me. 190 Q; did Hayden lunge at A: He was in motion. 191 Q: Murdock A: Like he didn't stop and then jump, it was just he was in motion running down the hill towards the three of us. 197 Q: She was standing on the road for eight to ten minutes before the dog bite? A: We were talking, I thought you said walking towards the front. So, it would probably be about five, six minutes from the time she was there and I was kneeling down that we were talking. 220 Q:....so you're standing in the position as it is in Exhibit 1. You're having a conversation with Debbie for about five to six minutes. You don't know where Hayden is, you didn't know that he was there anywhere 221 A: Hayden, if Hayden came down, whether he was coming to see Murdock or his grandmother it was we were all in the same vicinity. Whether we were two, three feet apart or whatever. So, it would have been up the driveway because I wasn't getting up and moving around with Murdock. 237 Q: back to Exhibit 1, this red line that you've drawn on, kind of showing the direction of where Hayden came from, the beginning of the line starts kind of right behind the circular little garden that's got some rocks around the outside: A: okay 238 Q Is the red line accurate as to where you first saw Hayden? Did you first see him when he was
6 6 A: I just saw him coming [21] [22] From that testimony it is clear that the owner was aware of the child running towards the two adults and two dogs who were in the same vicinity. It is clear that the owner was at all times crouched down beside his dog holding his collar for the very purpose of controlling the dog's activities and never let him go. The excited dog lunged at the moment when the child neared the group. Despite the owner's hold on the dog there was a moment of contact. The owner was doing everything he should and he is clear in answering that it was reasonable to rely on the control he had over the dog: "161 Q: Did you yell at Hayden to stop running? A: No, I had the dog. [23] I find no blame in the conduct of the owner, but there is liability by statute. [24] I find it was reasonable for the Grandma to rely on the control the owner had over the dog. [25] I have already observed that letting the child run about on the lawns while walking with him in the neighbourhood does not constitute "unattended" to bring the circumstances within the case law relied on by the Defendants. [26] There is no evidence, considering only the version most favourable to the Defendant, upon which Third Party negligence could be found. [27] Accordingly, Summary Judgment is granted, dismissing the claim against the Third Party. [28] Both the owner and the Grandma, by their actions and the tone of their testimony, seem like nice people being friendly, responsible neighbours until interrupted by the momentary contact between the child and an excited dog, and the more so by litigation using terms of blameworthiness. [29] If it is necessary to address costs, the Third Party may submit written argument of no more than two pages, together with a bill of costs and any offers, to the judicial secretary in Bracebridge by June 8, The Defendants may respond with no more than two pages by June 15, 2018 and any reply by June 19, suce M.P. Eperhan Released: May 24, 2018
Argued May 9, 2017 Decided September 5, Before Judges Messano and Espinosa.
NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT THE APPROVAL OF THE APPELLATE DIVISION This opinion shall not "constitute precedent or be binding upon any court." Although it is posted on the internet, this opinion is binding
More informationWritten by Deb Colgan of Riley s Place published on October 24, 2008
How to Meet a Dog Written by Deb Colgan of Riley s Place published on October 24, 2008 We've all either seen it or heard about it. You, your child, a friend... name it... goes to meet a dog who looks perfectly
More informationTEXAS DOG BITE CLAIMS
TEXAS DOG BITE CLAIMS C. Brooks Schuelke Schuelke Law Firm PLLC Table Of Contents Texas Dog Bite Problems 01 What Are Your Claims? 02 Does Texas Have A "One-Bite" Rule? 03 Make Your Claim As Soon As Possible
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS KATHY KOIVISTO, Plaintiff-Appellant, FOR PUBLICATION January 8, 2008 9:00 a.m. v No. 272943 Gogebic Circuit Court DAVE DAVIS d/b/a CHIEFTAN KENNELS, LC No. 05-000301-NO
More informationState of New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division Third Judicial Department
State of New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division Third Judicial Department Decided and Entered: December 29, 2005 97764 DYLAN LOPER, an Infant, by SUSAN M. LOPER, et al., His Parents and Guardians,
More informationONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE ) ) ) ) Plaintiff ) ) ) ) Defendant. ) J. Keenan Sprague, for the Plaintiff REASONS FOR DECISION
CITATION: Camilleri v. Brunet, 2016 ONSC 7312 COURT FILE NO.: CV-14-118588 DATE: 20161123 ONTARIO SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE BETWEEN: Nicole Camilleri J. Keenan Sprague, for the Plaintiff Plaintiff and
More informationClient Information. Doggie Information
Client Information Client (Person) Name: Emergency contact(s) & numbers: Street Address: City, State, Zip: Phone1: Phone2: Phone3: Email: Alternate contacts: Who is authorized to pick up/drop off your
More informationIN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA MISSOULA DIVISION
Case 9:08-cv-00014-DWM Document 106 Filed 01/28/11 Page 1 of 8 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA MISSOULA DIVISION DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, et al., No. CV-08-14-M-DWM Plaintiffs,
More informationWHAT MAKES A GOOD PET NEIGHBOR?
WHAT MAKES A GOOD PET NEIGHBOR? Pets make a neighborhood better. We increase social interaction, encourage activity for good health and even help people feel safer. But we need you to help make sure everyone
More informationThird District Court of Appeal State of Florida
Third District Court of Appeal State of Florida Opinion filed November 30, 2016. Not final until disposition of timely filed motion for rehearing. Nos. 3D16-314 & 3D15-2609 Lower Tribunal No. 13-18732
More informationKachenkov v Vadala 2013 NY Slip Op 30971(U) May 3, 2013 Sup Ct, Queens County Docket Number: 12736/11 Judge: Bernice Daun Siegal Republished from New
Kachenkov v Vadala 2013 NY Slip Op 30971(U) May 3, 2013 Sup Ct, Queens County Docket Number: 12736/11 Judge: Bernice Daun Siegal Republished from New York State Unified Court System's E-Courts Service.
More informationThe Story of Peter and the Wolf. Once upon a time, there was a young boy named Peter. Peter lived with his grandfather near a big green
The Story of Peter and the Wolf By Sergei Prokofiev (Revised to include 1 st grade and 2 nd grade Dolch and 1 st grade and 2 nd grade Fry sight words) Once upon a time, there was a young boy named Peter.
More informationPlease initial and date as your child has completely mastered reading each column.
go the red don t help away three please look we big fast at see funny take run want its read me this but know here ride from she come in first let get will be how down for as all jump one blue make said
More information"My Friend Earl" As told by Clayton Roo
"My Friend Earl" As told by Clayton Roo My name is Clayton Roo. My nickname is Roo. Everybody calls me Roo. When I was one year old, my owners came home with a little black dog that became a brother to
More informationDOG BITES 101 IN ARKANSAS. Recovery can be sought from not only the animal s owner, but sometimes from other responsible individuals as well
DOG BITES 101 IN ARKANSAS Recovery can be sought from not only the animal s owner, but sometimes from other responsible individuals as well Wesley A. Cottrell Each year, thousands of Americans suffer animal
More informationTitle 6. Animals* Chapters: 6.05 Dangerous Dogs 6-1. * For nuisance provisions regarding animals, see LMC , , and
Title 6 Animals* Chapters: 6.05 Dangerous Dogs * For nuisance provisions regarding animals, see LMC 8.10.040, 8.10.050, and 8.10.180. 6-1 Lyons Municipal Code 6.05.020 Chapter 6.05 Dangerous Dogs Sections:
More informationSquinty, the Comical Pig By Richard Barnum
Squinty, the Comical Pig By Richard Barnum Chapter 2: Squinty Runs Away Between the barking of Don, the dog, and the squealing of Squinty, the comical pig, who was being led along by his ear, there was
More informationEssential Elements that Require Vocabulary Word DLMEE DLMEE DLMEE DLMEE CCSS CCSS CCSS. Priority
Priority Score AAC Core Essential Elements that Require Vocabulary Word DLMEE DLMEE DLMEE DLMEE CCSS CCSS CCSS more 247 1 EE.SL.K.3 EE.L.K.5.b EE.RI.1.4 EE.L.4.1.d L.K.5.b RL.1.9 L.1.1.h you 228 1 EE.L.1.1
More informationDurham Kennel Club. Disruptive Dog Policy
Durham Kennel Club Disruptive Dog Policy Instructor Rights and Responsibilities (as they pertain to disruptive dogs) 1. Instructors have the responsibility to see that all handlers and dogs enrolled in
More informationPuppy Aptitude Test Form
Puppy Aptitude Test Form puppy (color, sex) litter date SOCIAL ATTRACTION Place puppy in test area. From a few feet away the tester coaxes the pup to her/him by clapping hands gently and kneeling down.
More informationAN INSIDER S GUIDE DOG ATTACKS. Zinda Law Group, PLLC. Attorneys at Law
AN INSIDER S GUIDE DOG ATTACKS Zinda Law Group, PLLC Attorneys at Law 1 Zinda& Davis, PLLC All Rights Reserved Contact Information: Austin Area: *Principal Office* 8834 N. Capital of Texas Highway Suite
More informationR.S.O. 1990, CHAPTER D.16
Français Dog Owners Liability Act R.S.O. 1990, CHAPTER D.16 Consolidation Period: From January 1, 2007 to the e-laws currency date. Last amendment: 2006, c. 32, Sched. C, s. 13. Skip Table of Contents
More informationFIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL STATE OF FLORIDA
FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL STATE OF FLORIDA No. 1D17-1481 DEBORAH DAVISON, Appellant, v. REBECCA BERG, Appellee. On appeal from the Circuit Court for Nassau County. Steven M. Fahlgren, Judge. March
More informationMINUTES OF THE APPEALS COMMITTEE Sitting as the Vicious Dog Appeal Committee
TOWN OF WHITCHURCH-STOUFFVILLE MINUTES OF THE APPEALS COMMITTEE Sitting as the Vicious Dog Appeal Committee APPEAL OF A NOTICE TO MUZZLE IN ACCORDANCE WITH BY-LAW 1999-135-RE AS AMENDED HEARD ON THE 16
More informationA short story by Leo Schoof, Kelmscott, Western Australia. My new dog
Page 1 of 9 My new dog My name is Freddy and next week it will be my twelfth birthday. I was quite excited about that. My father asked me what I would like to get for my birthday. I would love to get a
More informationFirst-Time Dog Owner Reveals How to chew train a rambunctious 6-month old puppy in Just 14 days
Are you still struggling to stop a puppy from chewing everything in sight? FirstTime Dog Owner Reveals How to chew train a rambunctious 6month old puppy in Just 14 days stop a puppy from chewing everything
More informationThe Gunshy Dog. By Wally "LCK" Hendricks
The Gunshy Dog. By Wally "LCK" Hendricks Most experts agree that gunshyness in dogs is by far a man made condition. There are some dogs that are born shy and are immediately shy to the gun without early
More informationISBN 13: ISBN 10: Library of Congress Number:
First Printing: January 2008 Copyright 2008 by Stephanie Z. Townsend. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission of the publisher except
More informationMIND TO MIND the Art and Science of Training
1 Mind to Mind Clicking For Stacking Most people think that a dog is conformation trained if it walks on a leash and doesn t sit or bite the judge. Professionals know that training a dog for the Specials
More informationDep t of Health & Mental Hygiene v. Schoentube OATH Index No. 1677/17 (Mar. 10, 2017)
Dep t of Health & Mental Hygiene v. Schoentube OATH Index No. 1677/17 (Mar. 10, 2017) Evidence established that two dogs, Jacob and Panda, are dangerous under the New York City Health Code because they
More informationWALTER J. ROTHSCHILD JUDGE Panel composed of Judges Susan M. Chehardy, Walter J. Rothschild, and Fredericka Homberg Wicker
NO. ll-ca-832 FIFTH CIRCUIT AMERICAN ALTERNATIVE INSURANCE COMPANY, CANON HEALTH CARE, LLC/T.L.H.C. AND CANON HOSPICE, LLC COURT OF APPEAL STATE OF LOUISIANA ON APPEAL FROM THE TWENTY-FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
More informationHide and Odour Officials Ann Gunderson and Allison Maxwell Judges Eileen Tuulos, Ann Gunderson and Allison Maxwell
K9 ABC GAMES February 10, 2018 Location: The Granbois Facility, 114-232 Street, Langley, BC Hide and Odour Officials Ann Gunderson and Allison Maxwell Judges Eileen Tuulos, Ann Gunderson and Allison Maxwell
More informationWhy Rabbits Have Long Ears And Short Tails By Jim Peterson
Why Rabbits Have Long Ears And Short Tails By Jim Peterson 2012 James Peterson Why Rabbits Have Long Ears And Short Tails By Jim Peterson As with most stories that deal with history there may be some who
More informationFarmers' Liability for Their Animals
Agricultural publication G453 Reviewed October 1, 1993 Farmers' Liability for Their Animals Stephen F. Matthews and Michael Mowrer Department of Agricultural Economics, University of Missouri-Columbia
More information>> PLEASE RISE. LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, THE FLORIDA SUPREME COURT. PLEASE BE SEATED. >> THE NEXT CASE ON THE COURT'S CALENDAR IS JARDINES VERSUS STATE.
>> PLEASE RISE. LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, THE FLORIDA SUPREME COURT. PLEASE BE SEATED. >> THE NEXT CASE ON THE COURT'S CALENDAR IS JARDINES VERSUS STATE. >> MAY IT PLEASE THE COURT. HOWARD BLUMBERG, ASSISTANT
More informationBiting Beth Bradley All Bites are Not Created Equal Teaching Puppies Bite Inhibition
Biting Beth Bradley If you have a dog in your life, you know that domestic dogs retain some of the instincts and impulses of their canine ancestors: If it moves, chase it! If it stinks, roll in it! If
More informationDog Behavior Questionnaire
Dog Behavior Questionnaire Please answer the following questions as completely as possible (use the margins and the back of the pages if needed) and return the completed form by mail or fax 48 hours before
More informationBLUE RIBBON TASK FORCE ON TETHERING MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING. October 29, 2013
BLUE RIBBON TASK FORCE ON TETHERING MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING October 29, 2013 A regular meeting of the Blue Ribbon Task Force on Tethering was held on Tuesday, October 29, 2013, at 12:00 p.m. in Conference
More informationA Toddler Safe Swissy. Well, Almost! By Connie L. McLean
I wish I could guarantee that if you do everything I suggest, your child will never be bowled over and sent sailing through the air by your darling little puppy. However, if you follow many of these suggestions,
More informationDemi s Animal Rescue Foster Agreement (Dog)
Demi s Animal Rescue Foster Agreement (Dog) Date Animal s Name: Breed: Sex: Weight: Age: Microchip ID: Notes: The parties agree that the foster shall abide by the following conditions: 1. (Name) hereinafter
More informationThis Assistance Dogs International Public Access Evaluation Is Being Shared With You for Educational Purposes Only!
This Assistance Dogs International Public Access Evaluation Is Being Shared With You for Educational Purposes Only! Passing This Test Does Not Imply, Certification By Assistance Dogs International! Assistance
More informationSTATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION DIVISION OF FLORIDA LAND SALES, CONDOMINIUMS, AND MOBILE HOMES
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION DIVISION OF FLORIDA LAND SALES, CONDOMINIUMS, AND MOBILE HOMES IN RE: PETITION FOR ARBITRATION SUNSET GROVE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION,
More informationBe Safe with Dogs: Advice for You and Your Family
Be Safe with Dogs: Advice for You and Your Family Dogs are not inherently aggressive and will usually only bite or chase when provoked. Dog bites in Palestine are not common, with only a small number being
More informationPLAY ALL DAY, LLC REGISTRATION FORM
Today s Date: How Did You Hear About Us? Owner(s) Name(s) Home Address City, State, Zip PLAY ALL DAY, LLC REGISTRATION FORM Start Date: OWNER INFORMATION Home Phone ( ) Work Phone ( ) Cell Phone ( ) Other
More informationHOW TO PREVENT ESCAPES...AND WHAT TO DO IF YOUR DOG GETS AWAY
HOW TO PREVENT ESCAPES...AND WHAT TO DO IF YOUR DOG GETS AWAY "HELP! MY DOG'S GONE!" ALL TOO OFTEN, RESCUE AND SHELTER VOLUNTEERS RECEIVE FRANTIC CALLS FROM PEOPLE WHEN THEIR BELOVED DOG ESCAPES. EVEN
More informationIN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE AT JACKSON September 19, 2017 Session
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF TENNESSEE AT JACKSON September 19, 2017 Session 10/19/2017 COREY M. SEARCY, ET AL. v. WALTER AXLEY, ET AL. Appeal from the Circuit Court for Benton County No. 14-CV-27 Charles
More informationX X X X X X X X X X X X X X X ORAL AND VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF GARY DONOVITZ, M.D., produced as a witness at the instance of the Plaintiffs,
NO. 0- SON TRAN and TRAM DO, Individually and as Next Friends of Hannah Tran, a Minor, Plaintiffs, vs. THERESA M. PATTON, M.D., THERESA M. PATTON, M.D., P.A.; and METHODIST HOSPITALS OF DALLAS d/b/a METHODIST
More informationMIKE BOYD, MR. LEONARD: May I proceed? THE COURT: You may. DIRECT EXAMINATION. Q. Mr. Boyd, please introduce yourself to the Court.
0 ::0 Who is that? :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: ::0 :: :: :: ::0 :: ::0 ::0 ::0 ::0 :: :: :: :: :: MR. LEONARD: The State calls Mike Boyd. MIKE BOYD, Having been first duly sworn by the Court, testified
More informationIN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM v. Case No. 5D09-588
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2009 MARIE TATMAN AND CHARLES TATMAN, Appellant, v. Case No. 5D09-588 SPACE COAST KENNEL CLUB, INC., ET AL., Appellee. /
More informationCHAPTER 604 TOWN OF SCARBOROUGH ANIMAL CONTROL ORDINANCE
CHAPTER 604 TOWN OF SCARBOROUGH ANIMAL CONTROL ORDINANCE Adopted 02/16/2000 Amended 05/19/2004 Amended 04/20/2011 Amended 05/07/2014 604-1 Purpose... 1 604-2 Definitions... 1 1. ABANDONED ANIMAL:... 1
More informationAPPLICATION. Cell phone.
333 North Bedford Road Mt. Kisco, NY 10549 Phone: 914-218-8258 Fax: 914-218-8259 Website: ckatthepark.com APPLICATION Owner Information Name Address Date Home phone Work phone Cell phone Email Services
More information(2) "Vicious animal" means any animal which represents a danger to any person(s), or to any other domestic animal, for any of the following reasons:
505.16 VICIOUS AND DANGEROUS ANIMALS (a) Definitions. The following definitions shall apply in the interpretation and enforcement of this section: (1) "Director of Public Safety" means the City official
More informationWe also wish to extend our sincere appreciation to Lisa Makarchukall and Martin Murtonen, Illustrators, and Rick Helmke, Photographer.
Fido, Friend or Foe? i Acknowledgements We wish to thank Doctors Bradecamp and Freeman, the authors of Fido, Friend or Foe? for sharing their activity book with us and for allowing us to incorporate some
More informationVisual Reward/Correction. Verbal Reward/Correction. Physical Reward/Correction
SIT - STAY DRILL The Sit-Stay Drill is a one-on-one training tool designed to help you learn perfect timing for when and how to reward positive behavior. Consistently rewarding positive behavior and correcting
More informationSample Course Layout 1
Sample Course Layout 1 Slow down here Finish here Lure Baby L1 Start L2 Drawing not to scale Because the Lure Baby is a drag lure machine (that is, it only goes one way), you will be able to start your
More informationDAYCARE / BOARDING APPLICATION
Date: DAYCARE / BOARDING APPLICATION OWNER INFORMATION Address: City: Zip Code: Home phone: Cell: Work: E-mail Address: EMERGENCY CONTACT INFORMATION (someone t traveling with you) Relation: Home phone:
More informationSTATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION DIVISION OF FLORIDA LAND SALES, CONDOMINIUMS, AND MOBILE HOMES
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION DIVISION OF FLORIDA LAND SALES, CONDOMINIUMS, AND MOBILE HOMES IN RE: PETITION FOR ARBITRATION STONE S THROW CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION,
More informationGone Fishing Trial Central Arizona Rat Patrol Mortimer's Country Store and Farm Hwy 69 and 169, Dewey-Humboldt, AZ
Dogs are required to have a Barn Hunt Registration number. To register your dog online: http://www.barnhunt.com Schedule Saturday AM Trial 1 7:15-7:45 am Check in 7:45 am Judge s briefing 8:00am Instinct
More informationWalking Your Dog on a Loose Leash
Walking Your Dog on a Loose Leash Information adapted from original article in the 5/2017 issue of the Whole Dog Journal by Nancy Tucker, CPDT-KA No one enjoys walking with a dog that constantly pulls.
More informationTHE BUTTERFLY AND THE KITTEN
1 THE BUTTERFLY AND THE KITTEN Written and Illustrated by Finley Keller The Butterfly and The Kitten Children s Stories From Keller Farms - Vol 2 2012 Finley J. Keller All rights reserved. No part of this
More informationMUST REGISTER IN PERSON AT:
Registration Packet MUST REGISTER IN PERSON AT: Community Recreation Center 505 N. Springinsguth Road Schaumburg, Illinois 60194 Tel: 847/490-7020 Fax: 847/490-2498 120 Remington Road, Schaumburg ParkFun.com
More informationì<(sk$m)=bdcjia< +^-Ä-U-Ä-U
Suggested levels for Guided Reading, DRA, Lexile, and Reading Recovery are provided in the Pearson Scott Foresman Leveling Guide. Sally and the Wild Puppy by Evan Allen illustrated by Bob Brugger Genre
More informationAND WHEREAS by motion 13-GC-253 the Council of the Corporation of the Town of Bracebridge deems it expedient to amend By-law ;
A BY-LAW OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF BRACEBRIDGE TO REQUIRE THE LICENSING OF DOGS AND FOR THE CONTROL OF DOGS WITHIN THE TOWN OF BRACEBRIDGE WHEREAS Section 8 of the Municipal Act, S.O. 2001, (hereinafter
More informationIN THE COUNTY COURT IN AND FOR BAY COUNTY, FLORIDA
Filing # 35984288 E-Filed 12/29/2015 03:25:17 PM IN THE COUNTY COURT IN AND FOR BAY COUNTY, FLORIDA BAY COUNTY ANIMAL CONTROL, Petitioner/Appellant vs. Case No.: 2015-2797-CC JOHNATHON JONES, Respondent/Appellee.
More informationElly and Aargh! Emma Laybourn.
Elly and Aargh! Emma Laybourn www.megamousebooks.com 2 Elly and Aargh! Four young dinosaurs were having a race. It wasn t a running race. They were ankylosaurs, which meant that they were covered with
More informationArticle VIII. Potentially Dangerous Dogs and Vicious Dogs
Sec. 7-53. Purpose. Article VIII. Potentially Dangerous Dogs and Vicious Dogs Within the county of Santa Barbara there are potentially dangerous and vicious dogs that have become a serious and widespread
More informationThe Development of Behavior
The Development of Behavior 0 people liked this 0 discussions READING ASSIGNMENT Read this assignment. Though you've already read the textbook reading assignment that accompanies this assignment, you may
More informationQUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL CITATION: PARTIES: APPLICATION NO/S: MATTER TYPE: Balens v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2018] QCAT 297 MARK ANDREW BALENS (applicant) v MORETON BAY REGIONAL
More informationGrand Rapids Housing Commission Ransom Tower Pet and Service Animal Policy
Grand Rapids Housing Commission Ransom Tower Pet and Service Animal Policy Residents who live in Ransom Tower Apartments are permitted to own common household pets defined as A domesticated animal, such
More informationIvan Tsarevich, the Firebird and the Gray Wolf
Ivan Tsarevich, the Firebird and the Gray Wolf Once upon a time in a far away land, there lived a mighty tsar. The pride of the tsar's kingdom was a magnificent orchard, second to none. However every night
More informationLesson 4: Mock Trial: Jackson, Wyoming vs. Stone Fox
Lesson 4: Mock Trial: Jackson, Wyoming vs. Stone Fox All rise. The Superior Court of the State of Wyoming is now in session. The Honorable Judge (fill in the name with the student or lawyer/judge, teacher,
More informationThe Corporation of the Town of Essex. Appeal Hearing with Resped to a Notice to Muzzle
The Corporation of the Town of Essex Appeal Hearing with Resped to a Notice to Muzzle November 17, 2015 An Appeal Hearing with Respect to the Roelens Notice to Muzzle was held on Tuesday, November 17,
More informationPLEASE KEEP THIS PAGE FOR YOUR RECORDS
General Information about All Pets Dog Daycare DOGS ALL dogs must pass a temperament test prior to their first day of daycare. Temperament tests generally last 1 hour and an appointment is REQUIRED for
More informationBE SAFE AROUND DOGS. Tips and advice for all the family
BE SAFE AROUND DOGS Tips and advice for all the family Millions of people have dogs as pets. In fact we all probably meet dogs every day, at home or when out and about. Dogs come in all shapes, sizes,
More informationPayson s Handling Services
HANDLING, SHOWING AND TRAINING AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT effective day of 201 Between ( the Client ) with a name and address of Name Name Address Phone Cell Email address And Perry D. Payson dba Payson
More informationPuppy Play School CONTRACT
Puppy Play School CONTRACT This Contract is between the Monadnock Humane Society ( MHS ) Boarding and Daycare facility (hereinafter called the Kennel ) and the pet owner (hereinafter called the Owner ).
More informationIN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS THE CITIES OF JACKSONVILLE, LONOKE NORTH LITTLE ROCK AND BEEBE, ARKANSAS
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS ROADS, INC., RICHARD VENABLE, DARIUS SIMS, MIKE KIERRY and PHILLIP MCCORMICK PLAINTIFFS VS. NO. THE CITIES OF JACKSONVILLE, LONOKE
More informationDesperate owner of Darwin the Ikea monkey files suit to get her 'baby' back
Desperate owner of Darwin the Ikea monkey files suit to get her 'baby' back By Daily Mail Reporter PUBLISHED: 16:03 GMT, 16 December 2012 UPDATED: 16:57 GMT, 16 December 2012 The owner of a monkey caught
More informationGUIDELINES AND CHECKLIST FOR CONDUCTING A NSDTRC(USA) HOME VISIT FOR POTENTIAL ADOPTERS OF RESCUE TOLLERS
GUIDELINES AND CHECKLIST FOR CONDUCTING A NSDTRC(USA) HOME VISIT FOR POTENTIAL ADOPTERS OF RESCUE TOLLERS (Many thanks to Basenji Rescue and Transport for allowing the NSDTRC(USA) to utilize much of their
More informationS.A.F.E.R. 1 TRAINING MANUAL. (Showing Animals: Friendly, Effectively, and Responsibly)
S.A.F.E.R. 1 (Showing Animals: Friendly, Effectively, and Responsibly) TRAINING MANUAL WWW.HUMANESOCIETYHBG.ORG Building a Better Community for Pets and People Through Compassion, Protection, Education,
More informationBewfouvsft!pg!Cmbdljf!boe!Hjohfs!
Bewfouvsft!pg!Cmbdljf!boe!Hjohfs! The Story of two Little Bears On a day in summer two little bears were playing together on a hillside. What can we do, Blackie? Ginger asked her brother. There must be
More informationSUPREME COURT - STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NASSAU - PART 22. Justice. Submitted October 11, 2005 Plaintiff,
SHORT FORM ORDER SUPREME COURT - STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NASSAU - PART 22 Present: HON. WilLIAM R. lamarca Justice AMANDA L. MillER, Motion Sequence # 001 Submitted October 11, 2005 Plaintiff, -against-
More informationROBERT POTTER, Petitioner-Respondent, v. JERSEY CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT, Respondent-Appellant.
POTTER v. JERSEY CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT No. A-5242-10T3. ROBERT POTTER, Petitioner-Respondent, v. JERSEY CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT, Respondent-Appellant. Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division.
More informationBiting, Nipping & Jumping Up
PREVENTING THOSE BAD BEHAVIORS. Biting, Nipping & Jumping Up 2006-2011. www.boston-terrier-world.com THE PROBLEM WITH PUPPY AND DOG AGGRESSION Probably the most challenging aspect of working with aggression
More informationPanther Ridge Wild Feline Conservation Academy. Frequently Asked Questions
Panther Ridge Wild Feline Conservation Academy The Panther Ridge Wild Feline Conservation Academy is an intense feline centered education program for high school students who are interested in zoological
More informationHenry and Mudge In Puddle Trouble. The Snow Glory. When the snow melted and Spring came, Henry and his
LEVEL 2.5 7320 Henry and Mudge In Puddle Trouble Rylant, Cynthia The Snow Glory When the snow melted and Spring came, Henry and his big dog Mudge stayed outside all the time. Henry had missed riding his
More informationPLEASE READ ENTIRE AGREEMENT BEFORE SIGNING ACADIA CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. PET AGREEMENT
PLEASE READ ENTIRE AGREEMENT BEFORE SIGNING ACADIA CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC. PET AGREEMENT Owner(s) Address: Unit No: OF ACADIA CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., SUN CITY CENTER, FLORIDA Identification
More informationDOUGLAS COUNTY CANINE RESCUE FOSTER AGREEMENT
DOUGLAS COUNTY CANINE RESCUE FOSTER AGREEMENT NAME: DATE: D.C.C.R s first and foremost concern is for each and every animal s wellbeing. We must insure every animal s individual needs are met and will
More informationPeter and Dragon. By Stephen
Peter and Dragon By Stephen Once there was a fox named Peter, and he lived a normal life with his parents Elizabeth and Henry. Every day he would get water with a pail to help wash food for breakfast,
More informationMy Favorite Stray Cat:
My Favorite Stray Cat: Reading Fluency 3 As children begin to read on their own, they need lots of practice to get better. They need to be able to read words accurately, with expression, and at a good
More informationOPEN NINTH: CONVERSATIONS BEYOND THE COURTROOM K9TH PROGRAM...EVERYONE'S BEST FRIEND EPISODE 19 MARCH 23, 2017 HOSTED BY: FREDERICK J.
0 OPEN NINTH: CONVERSATIONS BEYOND THE COURTROOM KTH PROGRAM...EVERYONE'S BEST FRIEND EPISODE MARCH, HOSTED BY: FREDERICK J. LAUTEN 0 (Music.) >> Welcome to another episode of "Open Ninth: Conversations
More informationMANDATORY IN-PERSON REGISTRATION AT:
Registration Packet Limited annual memberships will be for sale to residents Thursday, Sept. 4, 2014. Non-resident registrations, pending availability, will be Wednesday, Oct. 1. MANDATORY IN-PERSON REGISTRATION
More informationCORYELL COUNTY RABIES CONTROL ORDINANCE NO
ORDINANCE NO. 2010-03 Section 1.1 Authority. SECTION 1 INTENT AND AUTHORITY These regulations are adopted by the Commissioners Court of Coryell County, Texas, acting in its capacity as the governing body
More informationChapter 3: Darwin's Cows. To Darwin, strangers are friends he hasn't met.
Chapter 3: Darwin's Cows To Darwin, strangers are friends he hasn't met. One day the two of us took a break from fossil hunting in a creek that wound through a DeSoto County, FL cattle ranch where I had
More informationHouse Breaking Methods
Before you start: Ask yourself if you have the time, patience and consistency to guide your new family member into your HOME! Remember: The way you welcome them into your home is the way they would respect
More informationTHE TALE OF PETER RABBIT. by Beatrix Potter
THE TALE OF PETER RABBIT by Beatrix Potter ABOUT Beatrix Potter was an English author. In her childhood she spent many summers in the English Lake District where she encountered many of the animals featured
More informationStep by step lead work training
Step by step lead work training This lesson plan is designed to guide you step by step on how to achieve loose lead walking. It may seem like a long winded approach but this is how you will achieve solid
More informationThe Beginning of the Armadillos
This, O Best Beloved, is another story of the High and Far-Off Times. In the very middle of those times was a Stickly-Prickly Hedgehog, and he lived on the banks of the turbid Amazon, eating shelly snails
More informationST NICHOLAS COLLEGE HALF YEARLY PRIMARY EXAMINATIONS. February YEAR 5 ENGLISH (Listening Comprehension) TIME: 30 minutes TEACHER S COPY
ST NICHOLAS COLLEGE HALF YEARLY PRIMARY EXAMINATIONS February 2013 YEAR 5 ENGLISH (Listening Comprehension) TIME: 30 minutes TEACHER S COPY Guidelines for the conduct of the Listening Comprehension Examination
More informationThe Bear Trap. Stevan Serban. Matice Srpske 10, Novi Sad, Serbia, Copyright 2016 Stevan Serban. All rights reserved.
The Bear Trap by Stevan Serban Matice Srpske 10, 21000 Novi Sad, Serbia, belka.heljda@gmail.com Copyright 2016 Stevan Serban. All rights reserved. EXT. A GLADE BY A PATH IN THE FOREST - SPRING - DAY PETE,
More information